Blog

Brackenridge Park and its master plan: what the city decided in 2017

The 2017 plan for the 343-acre park with the zoo, tea garden and Witte Museum: its three strategies, near-term projects and the trade-offs it weighed.

Where else in the city can you ride a miniature train past a zoo, sit in a historic outdoor theater, stroll a Japanese tea garden and stand at the edge of a Spanish colonial water system without leaving the grounds? That crowding of treasures is the appeal of Brackenridge Park and also the root of its troubles. It is about 343 acres, wedged between U.S. 281, Broadway and Hildebrand Avenue, and it serves a zoo, museums, a golf course, ball fields, picnickers and Easter campers all at once.

In 2017 the City Council decided what the park should become, by approving a master plan, a long document worth understanding because it explains why the work in and around the park looks the way it does. What follows is that plan as the city published it, a record of a decision and its reasoning, not a verdict on how the work has gone. The city's capital-project pages show the current status of any project.

What the plan is, and how it was made

The Brackenridge Park Master Plan is dated February 21, 2017, and the City Council approved it on March 2, 2017, according to the Parks and Recreation Department. The city commissioned it to shape the park's development and rehabilitation "for many years to come." The Transportation and Capital Improvements Department managed the project with the Parks and Recreation Department and the Brackenridge Park Conservancy, a nonprofit partner, and a design team of planners, landscape architects, engineers, archaeologists and historic preservation specialists did the work.

The plan notes that the park is a State Antiquities Landmark and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. It lies in City Council Districts 1 and 2. The team was asked to do three things: plan land use to keep a balance between fee-based and free space, write design guidelines for rehabilitating existing elements and designing new ones, and identify, prioritize and estimate the cost of future capital projects.

The process began with a public design charrette, before any recommendations were drafted. It went on to interviews with 23 stakeholders, a first draft presented to those stakeholders and the public, and seven more public meetings across the city that residents asked for. The plan reports that between 800 and 1,000 people voiced opinions along the way. The Neighborhoods and Livability Committee asked for an additional six "activity-based" events in the park itself, including a mock archaeological dig for children and a guided bike ride to study how pedestrians and cars interact. The department's 2016 notices invited residents to meetings at places such as the Lions Field Adult and Senior Center and the Guadalupe Cultural Arts Center, and the same notice ran in Spanish.

The three strategies

The plan's recommendations sort into three categories, which the council approved:

  1. Restore natural park features and improve water quality in the San Antonio River.
  2. Restore, preserve and articulate the park's cultural and historical features.
  3. Increase visibility and pedestrian access to and within the park.

In general, the plan says, the community supported each of these. Behind them sits a set of facts about existing conditions, and they explain the choices.

  • Fee versus free. The plan counts 41 percent of the park as fee-based land, 35 percent as open and free, 9 percent as free use with limits, and the rest roads, parking, water or other uses. The zoo and the Witte Museum, the biggest draws, are north of Mulberry Avenue and are fee-based institutions. Visitation is concentrated in that northern half, while lower-density uses such as the trails along Avenue A and the golf course dominate the south.
  • Impervious cover. Twenty percent of the park is buildings, paving and other solid cover, which the plan calls high for a natural area.
  • Pedestrian access. Vehicle access is generally good and pedestrian access generally poor, the plan says. Entrances are not well marked, connections offer nothing beyond a paved walk, and the northern part of the park, where visitation is heaviest, lacks pedestrian entrances.
  • History. The park holds the dam and the head of an acequia, an irrigation channel, that watered the agricultural lands around the Alamo; a buried Spanish colonial dam, the Upper Labor Dam; and the pump house of San Antonio's first waterworks, which the plan calls the oldest known industrial building in the city. Investment and planning, the plan says, had given that history little prominence.

The near-term projects

The plan said an initial set of recommendations could be funded in the 2017 Bond Election, and it named projects for consideration in the bond program.

  • Upper Labor Interpretive Area. A research investigation by archaeologists at the University of Texas at San Antonio found a head gate and much of what remains of the Upper Labor Dam. The project would expose and interpret the dam and repair the acequia's channel walls.
  • Avenue A hike and bike path. Avenue A south of Mulberry would close to cars, with exceptions for emergency, park maintenance and golf course vehicles, and become a riverside trail for people on foot and bicycles. A small parking area would go in off Mulberry, and invasive plants along the path would give way to native species.
  • A new pedestrian bridge. A universally accessible bridge would link Broadway, the Witte Museum and the east side of the park to the zoo and other destinations on the river's west bank.
  • San Antonio River wall repair. Sections of the river channel wall have been failing for years, the plan says, several projects had repaired failed sections, and many hundreds of feet more needed replacement.
  • Tuleta parking garage. The zoo, the Sunken Garden Theater and other destinations along St. Mary's Street suffer from insufficient parking, the plan says. A garage on San Antonio Independent School District land would add parking and also support events at Alamo Stadium and the district's convocation center.

Projects not on that list were marked unfunded and long-term, to be considered as money becomes available.

The long-term ideas

The long-range list is broader and shows what the plan wanted for the park's character.

  • Restore the river and its channels. Stabilize riverbanks between Hildebrand and U.S. 281 with methods that look natural, restore the Catalpa-Pershing Channel to a natural design, remove invasive plants and replace them with natives.
  • Treat stormwater as a resource. Use low-impact development techniques that reduce impervious surface and let stormwater soak in or be stored on site.
  • Seek national designations. The plan recommended pursuing National Historic Landmark status, which can give a property added protection and eligibility for preservation grants, and a National Heritage Area designation, which supports preservation, recreation and heritage tourism through partnerships without the federal government taking ownership of land.
  • Restore historic buildings. Pump House No. 1, for example, could be renovated for a new use such as a café.
  • Renovate the Sunken Garden Theater through a public-private partnership so it could operate year-round, while preserving Easter camping and daily picnic uses.
  • Improve the park's edges and entrances, create at least two new access corridors from Broadway, extend a path north under Hildebrand to the Headwaters at Incarnate Word, and add multi-use paths.

The trade-offs

A master plan is a set of choices, and this one made several that pull in different directions.

Cars versus people. The park was first conceived as a series of parkways, a park to be enjoyed from a vehicle, the plan observes, and use has since shifted toward walking without the roads changing. Closing Avenue A and building a garage at the edge both follow from that: fewer cars inside, parking at the perimeter. Residents were asked to weigh in on ideas such as closing parts of the road network and removing interior parking, and the plan lists the ideas put to the public.

Fee versus free. The plan sets goals that would keep the current free area as the minimum free area in the future and return fee-based uses to public use where possible, while encouraging institutions to treat their boundaries as a common park edge. The zoo and the museum are major draws and neighbors, and the plan wants them closer to the park, not walled apart from it.

Preserving history versus using the land. Exposing a Spanish colonial dam, restoring a waterworks pump house and removing a non-historic earthen road bridge all serve the cultural-history strategy, and each changes how the land looks and works.

Planning versus funding. The plan separates what a bond could fund from what it could not. Read it that way: the near-term list is a commitment to consider, and the long-term list is an aspiration.

Following what happens

The plan itself is in eight documents on the department's page, from the executive summary through public input, recommendations, environmental standards, transportation and parking, other systems, implementation and an appendix. The department can be reached at the reservations number, 210-207-7275. For the current status of projects, use the city's capital project updates and the department's pages, and for speaking at a public meeting, How to speak at a San Antonio City Council meeting explains the process.

For the neighbors the plan names, see Brackenridge Park, the zoo and the Japanese Tea Garden, The Witte Museum, The Japanese Tea Garden in Brackenridge Park and The DoSeum: a museum for children. The district around the park is covered in Brackenridge Park and the Garden District, and Parks and Recreation Department profiles the department that manages it. The department's plan page is at sa.gov/Directory/Departments/Parks/About/Plans-Surveys.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic