Blog
How to read a council agenda: consent items, pulled items and time-certain hearings
The City posts its council agenda on SASpeakUp 72 hours ahead. How to read consent items, pulled items and time-certain hearings.
By Monday morning, the agenda for Thursday's City Council meeting is public. The City of San Antonio posts it on SASpeakUp at least 72 hours before the meeting, which means a Thursday 9 a.m. session has its document up by 9 a.m. the Monday before. A resident who reads it that Monday has most of a week to decide whether an item matters, read the attached documents and sign up to comment. Most people never look. This is for them: a plain walkthrough of what an agenda holds, in the order the Council takes it up, and how to tell the routine items from the ones that fill the chamber.
It follows the City's own description of its meeting process. Where that description leaves a detail open, such as how items are numbered, the City Clerk's office is the one to ask.
Two kinds of meeting, two kinds of agenda
The Council holds two regular sessions a week, and they do different jobs.
- A Session. Thursdays at 9 a.m., except in the fourth week of the month, in the City Council Chambers in the Municipal Plaza Building, 114 W. Commerce St., first floor. This is where votes are taken.
- B Session. Wednesdays at 2 p.m. Staff give detailed presentations on policy issues, and no action is generally taken.
There are no meetings in July, which gives staff time to prepare the budget. Dates can shift for holidays or special events. The City Clerk can call a special meeting on written request from the mayor, the city manager or three council members.
For a reader the difference matters. To learn what the Council decided, look at the A Session agenda and its results. To learn what it is thinking about, the B Session agenda lists the briefings. Wednesday B Sessions: where council policy gets argued before it is voted and A Thursday A Session, item by item cover each in more detail.
Where to find it and when it appears
Agendas go up on SASpeakUp at least 72 hours before a meeting. The City's meetings page has a "View Agendas" button that leads there, and it links to a video archive of past meetings and a search for minutes. Printed copies are available outside the Council Chamber doors one hour before a regular meeting.
The 72-hour rule is easier to see in a table. It shows the latest the agenda can be posted.
| Meeting | Starts | Agenda must be posted by |
|---|---|---|
| A Session (Thursday) | 9 a.m. | 9 a.m. the Monday before |
| B Session (Wednesday) | 2 p.m. | 2 p.m. the Sunday before |
Those are the latest times the 72-hour rule allows, calculated from the City's description. An agenda can appear earlier. The posting rule comes from state open meetings law and applies to the City's boards too; the 72-hour agenda rule and what closed sessions may cover explains it.
The order of business
The City's meeting-process page lists the order in which the Council takes up a meeting. Knowing it tells you where to look and roughly when an item will come up.
- Roll call by the City Clerk. A quorum is at least six council members. The Council has ten district members and the mayor, eleven in all.
- Invocation and Pledge of Allegiance, and approval of past minutes.
- Points of personal interest. Members make announcements.
- Individual agenda items. These often include staff presentations and are the items most likely to need discussion.
- Consent items. Routine matters, followed by a vote on the group.
- Time-certain items. These include public hearings and are heard at their posted times or as soon as possible after.
The Council may also recess into executive session or for lunch.
Consent items, and what "pulled" means
Readers skip the consent agenda more than any other part, and a good deal of the City's business happens there. The City describes consent items as routine matters such as equipment, supplies and capital improvements. The Council typically votes on them together.
Routine does not mean small. A capital improvement can be a large contract, and a purchase of equipment can be a large sum. The label means the item is expected to be uncontroversial and needs no separate discussion.
A council member may "pull" a consent item for separate discussion and a separate vote. The item then leaves the group and is handled on its own. For a resident, a pulled item is a signal that at least one member has a question or an objection. If you are watching a meeting and hear an item number called out to be pulled, that is the moment to pay attention.
If you care about a consent item, you need not wait to see whether it is pulled. Read the attached documents beforehand, contact your council member's office and, if you like, sign up to comment.
Time-certain items and public hearings
Time-certain items are the ones the agenda schedules for a specific time. The City says they include public hearings. If a hearing is posted for, say, 2 p.m., the Council takes it up then or as soon as possible afterward, wherever it sits in the order above.
For someone planning to attend, this is the most useful kind of item, because it tells you when to arrive. Land-use matters, such as rezoning requests, are commonly handled as hearings, but the City's meeting page does not sort which categories are time-certain, so look to the agenda itself for the posted time and do not assume. Items on the agenda carry their own identifiers. If a prefix or code is unclear, the City Clerk's office, at 210-207-7253, can say what it means, and the agenda documents themselves usually carry a summary.
Closed sessions
The Council may meet in closed executive session for a short list of reasons: attorney-client consultation, real estate, economic development, litigation, contracts, and personnel or security matters. The agenda lists any closed session and the reason. The public cannot attend those portions, and decisions made in closed session must still be voted on in open session when action is required. That last rule comes from state law, so treat it as a pointer to the Texas Open Meetings Act.
A worked example, clearly hypothetical
Say a resident, whom we will call a neighbor, opens the agenda on Monday at 10 a.m. for Thursday's A Session. The details below are invented for illustration.
- The agenda has forty items. Thirty-two are marked as consent items. Four are individual items with staff presentations. Four are time-certain items, with hearings posted for 2 p.m.
- Our neighbor cares about one thing: a proposed contract to repave a street near her home. She finds it among the consent items.
- She reads the attached documents and sees the street, the amount and the contractor. She wants to know when the work will begin, which the summary does not say.
- She emails her council member's office on Tuesday and gets the answer. She decides she does not need to speak.
- On Thursday she watches online. Her item is not pulled and passes with the consent group.
Now change one detail: a member pulls the item. The Council discusses it separately, and the neighbor, who registered to comment on Tuesday, speaks for her three minutes. Either outcome is possible, and the point is that reading the agenda on Monday gave her options on Tuesday.
Terms that appear on the page
- Quorum. The minimum number of members who must be present for the Council to act: six of the eleven.
- Consent item. A routine matter taken up with others; any member can pull it.
- Pulled item. A consent item taken out of the group for its own discussion and vote.
- Time certain. An item scheduled for a posted time, a category that includes public hearings.
- Executive session. A closed portion of the meeting for the subjects the City lists: legal advice, real estate, economic development, litigation, contracts, personnel and security.
- Points of personal interest. Short announcements by members, early in the meeting.
- SASpeakUp. The City's portal for agendas, registration to speak and written comments.
- TVSA. The City's government television channel, 21, which carries meetings with captions.
How to speak, and by when
The City's participation page says you can register on SASpeakUp or on site at least 15 minutes before the meeting, and staff are available to help starting 45 minutes before. Each person gets three minutes. An organization with three representatives waiting gets nine minutes. Written comments are accepted from the posting of the agenda until one hour before the meeting, and you do not need to live in San Antonio to speak at Public Comment. The registration information is public record. Captions appear on TVSA, channel 21, and accessibility requests go to 210-207-7253.
Put those together with the table above and a timeline emerges for a Thursday 9 a.m. meeting. The agenda is up by Monday 9 a.m., written comments can come in any time after that until 8 a.m. on Thursday, and registration to speak closes 15 minutes before 9 a.m. The full instructions are in How to speak at a San Antonio City Council meeting, and the experience of speaking is described in three minutes at the podium: a guide to public comment.
Reading the agenda like a resident
A few habits turn the document into something useful.
- Start with the time-certain items. They tell you when the room will be busy.
- Scan the consent list for your neighborhood. Street names, parks and contracts you recognize are worth a look.
- Use the council district map. Items often affect a specific district, and how to find your council district and representative shows how to find yours.
- Open the attachments. The agenda line is a summary. The memo behind it has the numbers.
- Watch for pulled items. The video archive, via TVSA, shows what happened if you could not attend.
- Look back at the minutes. The City's records, kept by the City Clerk, document what passed.
For public records beyond the agenda, Public Records and Open Meetings describes the system and Office of the City Clerk describes the office that keeps it. The City's official meeting pages are at sa.gov.