Blog

San Fernando and the church completed in the 1750s

San Fernando Cathedral stands beside Main Plaza on a site chosen on July 2, 1731.

The captain of the San Antonio presidio walked the ground west of the river on July 2, 1731, and chose two things at once: a spot for a church and the outline of a square. The church became San Fernando Cathedral. The square, in the words of the Handbook of Texas, "may still be considered the center of San Antonio." Almost three centuries on, the cathedral stands on that same spot beside Main Plaza. What a visitor sees is not the 1731 church, or even the first stone church of the 1750s, but a building that has been burned, flooded, rebuilt, enlarged and restored many times over.

A date to handle with care

The title reflects a date that is given two ways. The city's timeline summary puts the completion of the church in the late 1750s. The Handbook of Texas entry on the cathedral says Gerónimo de Ibarra completed the church in 1755, which is mid-decade, not late. "In the 1750s" is true under both. Below, 1755 is the Handbook's account and "the 1750s" covers both. Anyone who has to cite a single year should name the source they use.

From a plaza to a church

The Handbook gives a run of dates for the first stone church:

  • July 2, 1731: Juan Antonio Pérez de Almazán, captain of the Presidio of San Antonio, selected the church site and laid out the central square for the villa of San Fernando de Béxar. He acted under Spanish instructions for the newly arrived Canary Islanders.
  • May 11, 1738: the cornerstone for the first stone church was most likely laid, though accounts differ.
  • 1748: the viceroy approved 12,000 pesos to complete the church.
  • 1755: Gerónimo de Ibarra completed the church.

Read together, the dates show a project that took 24 years from the day the site was chosen to the day the church was done, and 17 years from the likely cornerstone. The viceroy's 1748 approval of money to "complete" it suggests construction was well along by then and needed funds to finish.

The church served the settlers of the civil town. In 1731 Canary Islanders formed the villa of San Fernando de Bexar, which the Handbook calls the first regularly organized civil government in Texas. The church and the plaza were the civil center of the new town, while the presidio and its Comandancia, a few minutes' walk away on Military Plaza, were the military center. The Canary Islanders and the villa of San Fernando de Bexar covers the settlers, and The Spanish Governor's Palace covers the Comandancia.

Flood, fire and a rebuilt church

The eighteenth-century church did not come through unchanged. The Handbook lists the damage:

  • 1819: a flood damaged the church.
  • 1828: a fire struck.
  • 1829 and 1830: rebuilding followed.

San Antonio has always had to reckon with its river, and the flood of 1819 is an earlier chapter in a long story. The larger flood of September 9 and 10, 1921, which killed at least 51 people downtown, and the dam and channel built afterward are told in The flood of September 9-10, 1921 and Olmos Dam and the river bypass: how San Antonio tamed its river.

One event from the rebuilt church has passed into the city's lore. In 1831 James Bowie married Ursula de Veramendi there. The marriage puts the church at the center of the town's social life five years before the Alamo siege of 1836, and it is a reminder that a church is a place where a town's milestones are recorded as well as a building for worship.

The nineteenth-century rebuilding

Most of what a visitor sees dates from the 1800s. In 1868 a renovation began under the architect François P. Giraud, who razed the original bell tower and part of the nave. In 1872 the original dome fell. In October 1873 the new church was consecrated.

That sequence corrects anyone who assumes the cathedral's front is colonial. Giraud's design, which the Handbook describes, added a Gothic Revival nave, triple entrance portals, a gable roof, twin bell towers and buttresses. Gothic Revival is a nineteenth-century style, not an eighteenth-century one. The second bell tower was completed in 1902, so the twin-tower silhouette that now defines the building is, in its finished form, a product of the early twentieth century.

The dates make the point:

Element Date
Site chosen and plaza laid out 1731
First stone church completed 1755 (Handbook)
Flood damage 1819
Fire 1828
Rebuilding 1829 and 1830
Renovation by Giraud, original tower and part of nave razed from 1868
Original dome falls 1872
New church consecrated October 1873
Second bell tower completed 1902

From the completion of the first stone church in 1755 to the consecration of the new one in 1873 is 118 years. Put another way, the eighteenth-century church lasted 118 years, and the nineteenth-century church has now stood for 153, from 1873 to 2026.

How old is each part

The cathedral is the product of many dates, so "how old is it?" has several honest answers. Counting back from 2026:

Event Years ago
Site chosen and plaza laid out (1731) 295
First stone church completed (1755) 271
Flood damage (1819) 207
Fire (1828) 198
New church consecrated (1873) 153
Designated a cathedral (1874) 152
Second bell tower completed (1902) 124
Repairs before the papal visit (1987) 39

The Handbook says Giraud razed the original bell tower and "part of the nave" in 1868. That wording implies some of the earlier building was kept, since only part of the nave came down. Which parts of the present structure survive from the eighteenth century is a question for the cathedral staff or a preservation survey.

What the dates do show is that the site is the constant. The plaza was laid out in 1731, the church stood beside it by 1755, and every rebuilding since has kept the church where the first one was. That continuity of place ties the cathedral to the original civil town.

A cathedral from 1874

The year after the new church was consecrated, the role of the building changed. In 1874 the Diocese of San Antonio was formed, and the church was designated a cathedral. The title "cathedral" is a nineteenth-century one. For the first 143 years after the site was chosen, from 1731 to 1874, the church was not a cathedral.

The distinction is more than a technicality. A cathedral is the church that holds the seat of a bishop, so the 1874 designation tied this building to a larger institutional structure. the missions as living parishes covers the pastoral life of the city's Catholic churches, including the working parishes at the missions.

A legend the record rejects

A legend ties the cathedral to the Alamo. In 1889, Juan N. Seguín claimed that the remains of the Alamo's defenders were buried in the church. The Handbook of Texas says they are "almost certainly not." The Handbook's judgment shows why a local historian checks a story before telling it. The Alamo, February 23 to March 6, 1836 and The Alamo after 1836, from Army depot to church sale to state ownership cover the siege and its aftermath.

Restoration and a papal visit

The twentieth century added its own repairs. The Handbook records major restoration in the mid-1970s. It also notes that repairs were made before Pope John Paul II's visit on September 13, 1987. The visit is on the city's timeline as one of the notable events of the late twentieth century, and it shows a historic building still serving as a stage for civic and religious occasions.

For readers interested in how the city protects its old buildings, the cathedral sits inside the Main and Military Plaza local historic district, one of the 32 the Office of Historic Preservation lists. Leon Springs: the three-parcel historic district explains how those districts are counted.

The papal visit in context

The September 1987 visit by Pope John Paul II sits on the city's timeline beside the Alamodome's opening in 1993 and the Spurs' arrival in 1973. A visit of that scale tests a historic building: crowds, security and ceremony all need a site that can carry them. The Handbook's note that repairs were made to the cathedral before the visit shows the building being readied for a public event, as it had been for others since 1873. San Fernando is a working church as well as a landmark.

Visiting

San Fernando Cathedral is open as a place of worship, and its schedule of services and visiting hours is set by the cathedral. Its current schedule is the one to follow. A visitor can combine a visit with a walk across the nearby plazas: Main Plaza in front of the church, Military Plaza and the Comandancia a short distance away, and Market Square beyond. A walk through Spanish colonial San Antonio: palace, plaza and church covers the broader tour of Spanish colonial buildings.

A few habits help a visitor read the building:

  1. Look for the join between old and new. The nave and towers are nineteenth-century Gothic Revival, while the site itself is from 1731.
  2. Remember the second tower. The twin towers did not exist together until 1902.
  3. Keep the dates straight. The cathedral was designated in 1874, the church was consecrated in October 1873, and the first stone church was done by the 1750s.

The oldest thing about San Fernando is not its stone but its position. The square was laid out on July 2, 1731, and the church has stood at its edge ever since, whatever has happened to the building.

Related city government

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic