Blog
The 1995 base-closure fight over Kelly and Brooks
Kelly Air Force Base survived a 1993 listing, lost in 1995 and closed in 2001; Brooks closed in 2011. The two fights, kept apart.
Folks here tend to remember San Antonio's two famous base-closure fights as a single event, and the record says otherwise. Kelly Air Force Base was recommended for closure in two rounds, 1993 and 1995, and the city won the first. Brooks Air Force Base was not on the 1995 list at all. It was recommended for closure in the 2005 round and closed on September 15, 2011. Both stories matter, a decade apart, and mixing them up hides a pattern: a city that lost one base and then planned for the next.
This piece keeps them apart. It follows the Texas State Historical Association's entries on Kelly and Brooks, which give the dates and figures, and it describes the argument the way a local controversy reads in the public record, without taking a side.
What Kelly was
Kelly Field's story starts in November 1916, when Captain Benjamin Foulois chose a site to expand the Army Signal Corps' aviation work beyond Fort Sam Houston. Flying began on April 5, 1917, and the field took its name from Lieutenant George E. Kelly, who died in a 1911 crash at Fort Sam Houston. In World War II, Kelly and nearby Duncan Field were consolidated and the base became a materiel center, with women holding more than a quarter of its jobs by the war's end. After the Air Force became independent the field was renamed Kelly Air Force Base in 1947.
By 1989 the base had more than 25,000 military and civilian employees and a payroll above $721 million. It was one of the largest employers in the metropolitan area, and its work was depot maintenance, the heavy repair of aircraft and engines that keeps a fleet flying. That is why the base mattered to the local labor market: skilled trades and engineering jobs, with federal pay and benefits, all concentrated on one site.
1993: the first listing
Congress created the Base Realignment and Closure process to trim the Defense Department's excess facilities through an independent commission, so closures would not be settled base by base through political bargaining. The commission reviews a list proposed by the Pentagon, adds and removes bases and sends a final list to the President and then to Congress. A proposal alone does not close a base.
In 1993 the BRAC Commission put Kelly on its closure list, and local support kept it open. The campaign itself is a story for the local archives. What the sequence shows is that a base on the list can come off it, and that the community and its allies are a real part of the process.
1995: the second listing
In 1995 BRAC again recommended Kelly's closure, and this time the effort to save the base failed. The commission sent its recommendation to the President in 1995, and the federal law carrying out that round was enacted on October 3, 1995, according to a table of base-closure laws. The base would stay open six more years while its work changed hands.
Here comes one of the most discussed parts of the story: the depot maintenance work was privatized. Between 1995 and 2001 the Air Force privatized depot maintenance, and layoffs hit about 8 percent of the workforce, with most employees retiring, transferring or being reemployed. The details of the privatization, including how contracts were awarded and the arguments around them, are a separate, long and contested story that this piece does not try to settle.
July 13, 2001: inactivation
On July 13, 2001, the San Antonio Air Logistics Center was inactivated and the base closed. It became KellyUSA, a civilian industrial and business property. The Air Force's departure ended a stretch that had begun with the first listing eight years earlier.
The dates on one line: November 1916, site chosen; April 5, 1917, flying begins; 1947, renamed Kelly Air Force Base; 1993, first closure listing; 1995, second listing and the one that stuck; July 13, 2001, inactivation. The full conversion story is in From Kelly Field to Port San Antonio.
Brooks: a different round
Brooks began in 1917, when the Army set up a facility to train flying instructors. It started as Gosport Field and was renamed Signal Corps Aviation School, Kelly Field No. 5, on December 5, 1917. It became Brooks Field on February 4, 1918, after Cadet Sidney Johnson Brooks, Jr., died in a training accident. The base trained pilots from 1922 to 1931 and was renamed Brooks Air Force Base in 1948. Flying ended in 1960, when the base became the headquarters of the Aerospace Medical Center and turned to medical research.
In 2002 the facility was renamed Brooks City-Base. In 2005 the BRAC Commission again recommended closure, and the base closed officially on September 15, 2011. The Air Force Civil Engineer Center now manages it, and the Brooks Development Authority has turned the old base into a master planned community. The neighborhood today is described in Brooks.
So Brooks was no part of the 1995 fight. It had a different outcome, a different structure and a different decade. Any article that says both bases closed in 1995 has Brooks's dates wrong.
What each side argues
Closure fights follow familiar lines, and it helps to state them evenhandedly.
The case for closure. Supporters of the process argue that the Defense Department has more facilities than it needs and that every dollar spent keeping an underused base open is a dollar not spent on readiness. They argue that a commission is the fairest way to choose.
The case for keeping a base. Local leaders argue that a base is more than a payroll. It is a concentration of skills, a supply chain, schools and housing that took generations to build. They argue that the cost of closing includes losing a workforce that is hard to replace.
Both arguments are always made, and both carry some force. What the record shows about San Antonio is the outcome: the first listing in 1993 was survived, the second in 1995 was not, and the city then spent years building a civilian economy on the old sites.
The conversion
The results show in the 2017 numbers for Port San Antonio, the civilian name for the old Kelly site. That year it marked the centennial of flight operations with more than 80 tenants and over 12,000 workers, with a reported contribution of more than $5 billion to the local economy. A tenant list and payroll on that scale are a remarkable outcome for a closure, though the jobs are not the same jobs, and the 2017 number is the port's own report, not an independent measurement.
Brooks has a more mixed profile. It became a planned community, with homes, offices and open space on land that was once an Air Force campus. Its economic profile differs from Port San Antonio's industrial focus.
The numbers side by side
Comparing figures across decades is risky, because each count works differently, but a few comparisons give a sense of scale. In 1989 Kelly had more than 25,000 military and civilian employees. By 2017 the site's reuse as Port San Antonio had more than 12,000 workers across more than 80 tenants. Twelve thousand is a little under half of 25,000, so the conversion replaced a large part of the old payroll in headcount, though not necessarily in kind or in pay, and the port's figure is its own report.
Against the military presence that exists now, the old Kelly workforce looks large. Joint Base San Antonio had 74,713 direct employees in 2025, according to the Texas Comptroller. Kelly's 1989 figure of more than 25,000 is about a third of that (25,000 divided by 74,713 is 0.33). The two numbers describe different things: one is a single base in 1989, the other a multi-installation joint base in 2025. The comparison shows how much more of the local economy the military occupies in aggregate than any single base once did.
The same story, as a table
| Date | Event | Base |
|---|---|---|
| November 1916 | Site chosen for expanded Army aviation | Kelly |
| April 5, 1917 | Flying operations begin | Kelly |
| December 5, 1917 | Becomes Kelly Field No. 5, then Brooks Field on February 4, 1918 | Brooks |
| 1947 | Renamed Kelly Air Force Base | Kelly |
| 1948 | Renamed Brooks Air Force Base | Brooks |
| 1993 | First BRAC closure listing; local support keeps it open | Kelly |
| 1995 | Second listing; effort to save it fails | Kelly |
| July 13, 2001 | Inactivated; becomes KellyUSA | Kelly |
| 2002 | Renamed Brooks City-Base | Brooks |
| 2005 | BRAC recommends closure | Brooks |
| 2007 | KellyUSA renamed Port San Antonio | Kelly |
| September 15, 2011 | Brooks closes officially | Brooks |
Read down the Kelly rows and you see a base that was open for 84 years, from 1917 to 2001, and has been a civilian property for more than two decades since. Read down the Brooks rows and the span from the first flying school in 1917 to closure in 2011 is 94 years.
What the city learned
Three lessons seem plain from the dates.
- A listing is not a closure. Kelly's 1993 survival shows the process has stages, and outcomes can change.
- Closure takes years. Between the 1995 recommendation and the 2001 inactivation, six years passed. Between the 2005 recommendation and the 2011 closure at Brooks, six years passed again. Both gave the city time to plan.
- Diversification is the defense. The modern city has Joint Base San Antonio, which combined Fort Sam Houston, Lackland and Randolph in 2010, and a private-sector economy that includes finance, energy, health care and technology. Military pay and the San Antonio job market describes how large the military share still is.
The City Council's role in these fights belongs to the city's own records. The council's current structure is in San Antonio City Council, and how the budget absorbs a change in the tax base is explained in How to read the San Antonio city budget.
The dates and figures above follow the Texas State Historical Association's entries on Kelly Air Force Base and on Brooks Air Force Base. The BRAC process itself is set down in federal law and in the commission's reports, the place to go for the details of any specific recommendation.