Blog

The Council House Fight of 1840

A March 19, 1840 peace meeting in San Antonio between Texas commissioners and Penateka Comanche leaders turned deadly. What the record says.

Four years after the Alamo fell and six before Texas joined the United States, San Antonio was a frontier town of the Republic of Texas, and the place where Texans and Comanches came to talk. The meeting on March 19, 1840, was meant to be a peace conference. It turned into one of the best-known acts of violence in the city's history, and its consequences carried far beyond the town.

Most Texas histories call it the Council House Fight, after the building where the talks were held. What follows sets out the sequence as the Texas State Historical Association records it, the positions of both sides and the ways the event has been read. It describes a documented event and sticks to what the record establishes.

The setting

In 1840 the Republic of Texas was an independent country, and San Antonio was its southwestern frontier town. The town had grown from the Spanish settlement described in May 1, 1718 and the mission and presidio that founded San Antonio and The Canary Islanders and the villa of San Fernando de Bexar, and it had been the scene of a siege in 1835 and the battle of 1836; see The siege of Bexar, October to December 1835. The Alamo itself was in disrepair. (In that same year, 1840, the city council allowed residents to haul stone away from the ruins for a fee, a sign of how little anyone could have predicted the site's later standing. The building's long afterlife is the subject of The Alamo after 1836, from Army depot to church sale to state ownership.)

The Comanche people were a major power on the plains and across much of what became Texas. The group that came to San Antonio in 1840 were Penateka Comanches, one of the Comanche bands.

Why the Penatekas came

The Texas State Historical Association describes several pressures that led the Penatekas to seek peace in 1840:

  • Attacks from the north. Cheyenne and Arapaho attacks on the northern frontier of Comanche territory.
  • Disease. Losses from smallpox epidemics.
  • Military pressure. The successes of the Texas Rangers against them.

Under that pressure, Comanche peace representatives arrived in San Antonio in January 1840 to talk terms with commissioners appointed by Texas.

What Texas demanded

The Texas commissioners arrived with broad demands. According to the Texas State Historical Association, they required:

  1. The return of all captives.
  2. That the Comanches leave Central Texas.
  3. That they stop interfering with Texan incursions.
  4. That they avoid White settlements.

The first demand mattered most on March 19. The Comanches, like other groups on the frontier, had taken captives in raids, and the return of captives was a central grievance for Texans with relatives held. The other three demands reached further: they asked the Comanches to give up land and accept a boundary that Texas would define.

March 19, 1840

On March 19, thirty-three Penateka chiefs and warriors arrived in San Antonio. Thirty-two other Comanches came with them, and the delegation was led by a chief named Muk-wah-ruh.

They brought only a few captives. Among them were several Mexican children and Matilda Lockhart, a 16-year-old White girl. Muk-wah-ruh told the commissioners that the remaining captives were held by bands beyond his control. The commissioners rejected that explanation.

The meeting changed at that point. Texas soldiers entered the Council House and announced that the chiefs would be held as hostages until all the captives were released. The chiefs tried to escape and called for help from tribesmen outside. In the melee that followed, Texans attacked several of the Comanches, and soldiers killed most of those remaining in the courtyard.

The Texas State Historical Association gives the casualties as about thirty Penateka leaders and warriors and some five women and children killed by Texas troops. Texan casualties are counted in the fuller histories of the fight.

The aftermath that day

After the fight, Texas authorities freed one Comanche woman and sent her to secure the release of the white captives in exchange for twenty-seven Comanches who had been captured in the fight. The Penatekas refused.

No account of any individual captive's fate is offered here beyond what the Texas State Historical Association states.

How the Comanches saw it

The Texas State Historical Association records the Comanche view directly: the Penatekas considered the attack a violation of the immunity of ambassadors. A delegation that comes under a flag of peace to negotiate expects not to be seized. From that point of view, the Texans' decision to take the chiefs hostage turned a conference into a trap.

Led by Buffalo Hump, the Penatekas retaliated with raids deep into Texas. The same source states that Comanche hatred of Texans continued throughout the warfare era and contributed to frontier violence.

That is a notable statement of consequence. The Council House Fight is often described as one day's event, but the people who lived through the following years in the Texas interior treated it as the start of a period of sharper conflict.

How the Texans saw it

The Texas commissioners' position, as the record presents it, was that the Comanches had been told to bring all captives and had not done so. They considered the missing captives a breach of the terms of the meeting. Among the few captives brought in was Matilda Lockhart, a 16-year-old girl, so the stakes of the demand were personal for Texans with relatives held. Her own account of her captivity is a separate and painful chapter, told in the fuller histories.

On who decided to hold the chiefs, and when, the record is brief. The Texas State Historical Association says only that soldiers entered the Council House and announced that the chiefs would be held. Who ordered what, and when, is a question for the fuller histories.

The sequence in brief

Date Event
January 1840 Comanche peace representatives arrive in San Antonio
March 19, 1840 Thirty-three Penateka chiefs and warriors, with thirty-two other Comanches, arrive for the talks; the Council House fight follows
After the fight One Comanche woman is freed to arrange the captives' release; the Penatekas refuse the exchange
Following months Led by Buffalo Hump, the Penatekas retaliate with raids deep into Texas

Count the arrivals: 33 chiefs and warriors plus 32 others makes 65 Comanches in the delegation, and the Texas State Historical Association's casualty figures, about thirty leaders and warriors and some five women and children, add up to roughly 35 killed. That is a bit more than half of the party that arrived, a measure of how complete the loss was. These are sums of the published figures and not a count from a separate source, so they are only as exact as the original numbers.

Where the account differs

Different histories give different numbers and details, and some of the differences matter.

  • Casualty counts. Figures vary from one history to another. The Texas State Historical Association's numbers are used here.
  • Who started the shooting. The TSHA entry says the chiefs tried to escape and that the fighting broke out in the melee. Fuller histories may weigh the sequence differently, so read more than one.
  • The order of events inside the building. The summary is brief, and the first minutes are the part most open to interpretation.

A fair reading begins by remembering that every account was written by someone with a stake. In general, accounts by Texans of the period stress the captives and the Comanches' failure to comply, while the Comanche view, as the Texas State Historical Association states it, stresses the violation of ambassadors' immunity. Careful historians try to hold both. The account above does the same: it states what the Texas State Historical Association records, notes where its summary is brief, and leaves interpretation to the reader.

Why it belongs in a city history

The Council House Fight has a place in a city's history for three reasons.

It happened in town. The event took place in San Antonio, not on a distant battlefield. The building's exact address is a question for a local history, but the town of 1840 is the old core of today's downtown; see Downtown San Antonio. The old plazas and the market district are discussed in Market Square.

It shows how the town worked. San Antonio was where Texans, Tejanos and Native peoples met to trade, negotiate and fight. A city that now goes by the nickname Military City USA (see The Mexican War and the beginning of Military City USA) was, in 1840, a place where the main security question was the frontier.

It had consequences. The raids that followed the fight reached settlements across Texas. A single afternoon in a courtyard became a hinge in the region's history.

Reading the history responsibly

A few habits help when reading about the Council House Fight, and about events like it.

  1. Separate the sequence from the interpretation. The order of events is better documented than the motives.
  2. Notice who is speaking. Most surviving written accounts come from one side.
  3. Use specific numbers with their source. "About thirty" and "some five" are the Texas State Historical Association's formulations; other works differ.
  4. Avoid ranking suffering. The captives, the Comanche chiefs, the women and children killed, and the families of settlers who later suffered in the raids all appear in the record.

For anyone who wants more, the Texas State Historical Association's Handbook of Texas entry is the basis for this summary, and the Texas State Library and Archives and local archives hold the period's records. San Antonio's municipal archives are kept by the City Clerk, whose office is described on the city's pages at sa.gov.

A closing note on place

Visitors walking downtown today pass streets where much of this history is unmarked. What remains is a record. The date, March 19, 1840, and the number thirty-three, the chiefs and warriors who came to talk, are where to begin. Everything after is the work of reading carefully.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic