Blog
The 11-member Ethics Review Board and what voters changed in 2024
San Antonio's 11-member Ethics Review Board enforces the city's ethics, lobbying and campaign finance rules. What it does and what Proposition A changed.
Most city boards give advice and go home. The Ethics Review Board is one of the few that sits in judgment. Eleven residents, appointed by the council and the mayor, hold the job of applying San Antonio's ethics rules to the people who write and carry out the city's laws: council members, the mayor, appointed officials, city employees, lobbyists, and the candidates who run for council seats.
On November 5, 2024, the board got a quiet but real update. Voters approved Proposition A, one of six charter amendments on that ballot, with about 72 percent of the vote, the widest margin of the six. Ask around and few residents could tell you what it changed. What follows is the board, what Proposition A did, and where the paperwork is kept.
What the board is
It is a body of 11 citizens, appointed by the City Council and the mayor. It comes out of the city charter and is not a department of city staff, and the distinction counts, since the people it reviews include the very officials who appoint it. The city describes its purpose as enforcing the ethics code, the lobbying rules and the municipal campaign finance rules.
Those are three different kinds of rule:
- The ethics code. Standards of conduct for officials and employees: conflicts of interest, gifts, use of city resources, recusal when a personal interest is at stake, and the disclosures that go with all of it.
- Lobbying rules. Anyone paid to influence city decisions must register, and the activity is reported. Registrations and activity reports are public through the City Clerk.
- Municipal campaign finance. Candidates for city office file reports with the City Clerk on what they raise and spend, and the board enforces the city's own limits and reporting rules on those races.
The paperwork lands at the City Clerk's office. That is why the clerk's page on the city site carries sections on ethics complaints, formal and advisory opinions, disclosures and recusals, office holders' personal financial statements, lobbyist registrations and vendor conflicts of interest. The division of labor is simple: the board decides, and the clerk keeps the files. What the City Clerk keeps, from archives to passports describes what else that office holds.
Two doors: an opinion or a complaint
The city's ethics pages describe two main channels for the board's work.
Advisory opinions. An official or employee who is not sure whether a planned action would break the code can ask for an advisory opinion before acting. The answer goes on the record for the person to rely on, and it adds to a body of guidance for the next person with the same question. The city also lists "formal opinions," the board's written determinations.
Complaints. Someone who believes the code has been broken can file a complaint, and the board's process decides whether it goes forward. The city's page lists how to file. The steps, deadlines and penalties are set out in the ethics code and the board's procedures, so go to those instead of a summary. The code was revised for fiscal year 2025, according to the clerk's page, so an older description may be out of date.
A complaint to the board is not a criminal charge. Crimes belong to police and prosecutors, open-records disputes to the Texas Attorney General, and state officials answer to state bodies. The board's reach stops at the city's own code.
What Proposition A changed
News coverage and voter guides described the 2024 amendment as a set of modest changes to how the board works. Three stand out.
- A definition of conflicts of interest. The ballot language put a definition of the term into the charter, so that the board, officials and employees work from one text. The exact wording is in the charter and the city's ethics code.
- Sufficient funding. The city must give the board "sufficient funding" to carry out its assigned duties. A board that can be starved of money can be tamed, and the change answers that worry in the charter's own words.
- Declining resolved complaints. The board may accept or decline a complaint that another entity has already resolved. That spares it from repeating work a court, an agency or another process has already done.
The reported margin was about 72 percent in favor, higher than for any other amendment on the ballot. The narrowest were Proposition C, on the city manager's pay and tenure, at about 54 percent, and Proposition F, on four-year terms, at about 53. Coverage at the time called these early tallies for most of the amendments, so the certified totals may differ slightly.
The other 2024 amendments, in one paragraph
Proposition A did not travel alone. The package voters saw on November 5, 2024, included language modernization (Proposition B, about 68 percent), removal of the 2018 caps on the city manager's pay and tenure (C, about 54), the end of a 72-year ban on off-duty political activity by city employees (D, about 63), higher pay for council members and the mayor (E, about 64) and four-year terms for council and mayor (F, about 53). Ethics sits among them because several of the others, D and E in particular, change who can take part in politics and what officials are paid, the same ground where ethics questions tend to come up. The account of the term-limit change is in the ten council districts and how to find yours, and the story of the charter as a whole is in the 1951 charter and the commission that wrote it.
A case that is made up
Rules read better with a case, so here is an invented one, meant to show the mechanics and no real person.
Say a council member's sibling owns a small business that rents space in a building next to a lot being rezoned. A zoning case for that lot sits on the Thursday A Session agenda. The member is unsure whether the sibling's lease creates a conflict that calls for stepping aside from the vote.
There are choices. Before the meeting, the member can ask the board for an advisory opinion and have an answer on file. At the meeting itself, the city's disclosure and recusal process is the formal way to state the connection and sit out the vote, and those disclosures are among the records the City Clerk keeps and publishes. Either way, a neighbor who learned of the lease later and believed the code had been violated could file a complaint, and the board would decide whether it went forward. If another body had already looked at the same facts, Proposition A's language gives the board room to decline.
Nothing in the example is dramatic, and that is the point. Most ethics questions at City Hall are small, ordinary and about timing: who knew what before the vote, and who said so on the record. The board exists mostly to make those moments routine. Look at the order of operations. A good ethics process is mostly preventive: ask first, disclose, recuse. The complaint route is for the cases where none of that happened. The opinions the city publishes are worth reading before you decide a local controversy is unusual.
What the board does not do
It helps to be exact about the limits.
- It does not run elections. The City Clerk manages city elections and the county's Elections Department runs the voting. Who actually runs a San Antonio city election explains the split.
- It does not decide open-records disputes. Requests for city records go through the city's open records portal and the Texas Public Information Act; a denied request goes to the Attorney General, not the ethics board. how to request public records from the city and county covers the process.
- It does not replace the council. Voters can recall council members, and the council has its own rules of order. The board is one check among several.
- It does not give legal advice. An advisory opinion applies the city's code to a stated set of facts. It is no substitute for a lawyer and it does not bind other bodies.
How to keep an eye on it
The board is a public body. Its meetings fall under the Texas Open Meetings Act, so agendas are posted ahead of time and the room is open to the public, except where the law allows a closed session. The City Clerk's ethics pages are where to find:
- the text of the ethics code and recent revisions,
- how to file a complaint or ask for an advisory opinion,
- formal and advisory opinions the board has issued,
- personal financial statements that office holders file,
- the lobbyist registrations and activity reports, and
- the lists of employee and official disclosures and recusals.
To see the code at work, start with the opinions and disclosures. They are the most concrete part, because they show real situations and how the board applied the rule. If you want to speak on the board's work at a council meeting, the sign-up rules in How to speak at a San Antonio City Council meeting apply: register on SASpeakUp or in person at least 15 minutes before the meeting, and plan on three minutes.
Who sits on it
The charter sets the size at 11 and the method at appointment by the council and the mayor. Membership changes, and the City Clerk's boards and commissions pages list current members and vacancies. The same office takes applications, so a resident who wants a seat can apply through the City Clerk's online form. That is the answer to who watches the watchers: residents who apply, get appointed and serve.
For the official description of the body, see Ethics Review Board. For the quickest way to the underlying documents, start at the City Clerk's page on sa.gov, which links the code, the opinions and the filing forms in one place.