Blog

The McNay Art Museum

A painter built a house in 1927 and left it to become San Antonio's modern-art museum. The house, the 2008 addition and the two opening years.

Some museums are built to hold a collection. The McNay Art Museum is the other kind: it started out as somebody's house. The house, at 6000 North New Braunfels Avenue, near the edge of Alamo Heights on the north side of town, went up in 1927 for a painter and art teacher named Marion Koogler McNay. It became a museum after her death and still sits at the center of the campus, with a much larger gallery building added beside it in 2008.

The house and its owner

Marion Koogler McNay was an American painter and art teacher who inherited a large oil fortune when her father died. By the standard reference summary of the museum's history, she had a home built in 1927, designed by the architect Atlee Ayres and his son Robert M. Ayres.

When she died, McNay left the house so it could serve as a museum. That one sentence holds the whole origin of the institution, and it is unusual enough to pause on. Many American art museums grew from civic campaigns, groups of donors or universities. The McNay grew from one collector's decision about what should happen to a home. The collection she assembled, and the house that held it, were the foundation, and later directors and donors built outward from them.

The house itself

The house is Spanish Colonial Revival, described as a 24-room mansion. The property covers 23 acres, with fountains, broad lawns, a Japanese-inspired garden and a fishpond. Spanish Colonial Revival was the signature style of the Ayres firm. Atlee Ayres, who lived from 1873 to 1969, practiced mainly in San Antonio and central Texas, and in 1924 he formed a partnership with his son Robert. Their best-known skyscraper was the thirty-story Smith-Young Tower of 1929, which a biographical summary calls San Antonio's first skyscraper. The same summary lists a residence that later became the McNay as a firm commission, but dates it to 1928, a year later than the 1927 given elsewhere. A year's gap between a design date, a construction date and a completion date is ordinary for a large house, so the 1927 date is used here, with the one-year difference noted.

One museum, two opening dates

Try to answer the simplest question, when did the museum open, and two published listings disagree. The lead of the reference article says it was founded in 1954. The article's infobox lists the date of its establishment as 1950.

Neither the lead nor the infobox is wrong on its face, and a museum's own staff can usually say which date they mean when they say "founded." Both dates are plausible, because "founded" and "opened" can mean different things for a museum that starts with a bequest. A museum can be established legally when the estate is settled and the institution created, then open to the public some years later, after the house is made ready and a staff hired. Which meaning goes with which date is a question for the museum's own history, so both dates are given here, and a reader who needs one should ask the museum.

The arithmetic shows why it matters at anniversary time. Counting to 2026, a 1954 founding makes the museum 72 years old, and a 1950 founding makes it 76. Anyone planning an anniversary party should check the museum's own site for the year it uses, since an institution's own count is the one it will print on the invitations.

What the 2008 addition changed

The most visible event in the museum's recent history is the Jane and Arthur Stieren Center for Exhibitions, completed in 2008 and designed by the architect Jean-Paul Viguier. The reference summary describes a 45,000-square-foot building next to the original residence, housing special exhibition galleries, a sculpture gallery, a paper works gallery, a lecture hall and learning centers.

The new building answered a problem every house-museum faces: a house has rooms, not galleries. It also left the house intact, so a visitor can still step from a contemporary gallery into the 1927 building.

For scale, the Stieren Center's 45,000 square feet is roughly one and a half times the Rockefeller Center for Latin American Art at the San Antonio Museum of Art (about 30,000 square feet), a comparison drawn only to give a feel for the size. The two museums are separated by the length of the city's north-south axis, and each is described in its own piece; the river museum's story is in The San Antonio Museum of Art on the Museum Reach.

Walk it in that order, if you can: a cool, tiled house first, with its courtyards and its fishpond, then the long bright galleries of the newer building. The house sets the tone. It reminds you that these pictures were first collected by one person for her own walls, in a home meant to be lived in, and only afterward became a public trust.

The collection

The museum's focus, as the reference summary puts it, is mainly nineteenth- and twentieth-century European and American art. The article names Cézanne, Picasso, Matisse, O'Keeffe and Hopper among the artists represented. Over time the collection has grown to include medieval and Renaissance works, and the museum holds more than 20,000 objects in all.

The reference summary also names a handful of specific works: two panels by the Master of Frankfurt, Saint Barbara and Saint Catherine, both from about 1460; El Greco's Head of Christ, from about 1579; Odilon Redon's pastel Profile and Flowers, from 1912; and Amedeo Modigliani's Girl with Blue Eyes, from 1918. The artists named in the modern collection also include Gauguin, Diego Rivera and Mary Cassatt. Collections change as works are lent, rotated and acquired, so whether any of these is on view on a given day is a question for the museum.

The span of those dates is worth a look. From a panel of about 1460 to a painting of 1918 is some 458 years, so the museum's focus on nineteenth- and twentieth-century art is a center of gravity, not a limit.

Two further pieces of the museum are less obvious to a first-time visitor.

  • The Tobin Collection of Theatre Arts. The museum houses a collection devoted to the theater. The name Tobin also appears on the performing arts center downtown, a separate institution described in The Tobin Center and the Majestic Theatre; a visitor to one should not expect to find the other at the same address.
  • A research library. The museum has a research library with more than 30,000 volumes.

A museum with a library and a collection of theater arts is a research institution as well as a place to look at pictures. That is part of how it differs from a gallery, and it is the part most visitors never see.

Where it sits

The address, 6000 North New Braunfels Avenue, puts the museum north of the city's center, near Alamo Heights. Alamo Heights is one of the independent cities inside Bexar County, with its own government, and its relationship to San Antonio is described in Alamo Heights: a city inside the city, and why 78209 is not its border. The city's neighborhood listings identify the McNay as near Alamo Heights and Terrell Hills, and the neighborhood is covered in Alamo Heights.

That puts the McNay near the cluster of museums the city's listings place along Broadway and New Braunfels Avenue. The Witte Museum is at 3801 Broadway, beside Brackenridge Park; the DoSeum, a children's museum, is at 2800 Broadway; and the McNay is at 6000 North New Braunfels. The three together are the subject of The Broadway and New Braunfels Avenue museum mile, stop by stop. The park, the zoo and the Japanese Tea Garden nearby are in Brackenridge Park and the Garden District. The addresses come from listings and should be confirmed on each museum's site before a visit.

Visiting the McNay

Practical facts change, and the museum's own website is the place to get them. A few things can be said with confidence.

  1. Check hours and admission before you go. Hours and prices change, so confirm both with the museum before a visit.
  2. Plan to see the house as well as the galleries. The 1927 building and the 2008 building are different experiences, and the house is the reason the museum exists.
  3. Think of it as a stop on a longer day. The museums along Broadway and New Braunfels sit close enough that a family could combine two, though a single visit to any of them is a full outing.
  4. Look for low-cost options. The city guide to inexpensive activities, Free and low-cost things to do in San Antonio, is a starting point, though museum admission policies are set by the museums.

What the house says about the city

There is a longer story here about how art museums arrive in American cities, and San Antonio's have several origins. The Witte, in 1926, began with a businessman's bequest and a matching gift from the city. The San Antonio Museum of Art, in 1981, began as a branch separated from the Witte and moved into a former brewery. The Briscoe Western Art Museum, opened in 2013, moved into the city's old public library building, described in The Briscoe Western Art Museum. And the McNay began as a woman's house.

Each is a way of saying the same thing: a city's museums are made out of whatever the city had at hand, a collector, a brewery, a library, a bequest. The McNay is the clearest case of a private person's taste becoming public property.

The museum's own words about itself belong on its website. What the public record establishes is simple, and it is enough to place the McNay on the map: a 1927 house, a bequest, a 2008 expansion, a collection of more than 20,000 objects, and a research library of more than 30,000 volumes, all at 6000 North New Braunfels Avenue.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic