Blog
Trinity, St. Mary's, Our Lady of the Lake and Incarnate Word, compared
Four private San Antonio universities compared by founding, mission, campus and athletics: Trinity, St. Mary's, Our Lady of the Lake and Incarnate Word.
Say "the private schools" in San Antonio and people think of four campuses that religious bodies built in the nineteenth century and that have outlasted most of the institutions around them. Trinity University, St. Mary's University, Our Lady of the Lake University and the University of the Incarnate Word differ in size and mission and look alike only on a map. Three are Catholic. One began as a Presbyterian college. They sit in four different parts of town, and a student who visits all four will see four different ideas of what a university is.
The comparison below sticks to what is on the record: when each was founded, by whom, where it stands, how it describes itself and which athletic division it plays in. Nothing here ranks them, and there are no tuition figures, because those change every year and are laid out on each school's own pages. Enrollment varies from year to year, so figures are given in rough terms.
At a glance
| Trinity University | St. Mary's University | Our Lady of the Lake University | University of the Incarnate Word | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Founded | 1869, in Tehuacana, Texas | 1852, as St. Mary's Institute | 1895, as the Academy of Our Lady of the Lake | 1881, as the Incarnate Word School |
| Founders | Cumberland Presbyterians | The Society of Mary (Marianists) | The Sisters of Divine Providence | The Sisters of Charity of the Incarnate Word |
| Religious tie | Historically Presbyterian; independent since a 1969 covenant | Catholic, Marianist | Catholic, sponsored by the Sisters of Divine Providence | Catholic |
| Campus | About 125 acres north of downtown on a former quarry | About 135 acres, urban | About 72 acres, main campus | In Midtown Brackenridge and Alamo Heights |
| Athletics | NCAA Division III | NCAA Division II (Rattlers) | NAIA | NCAA Division I |
Trinity: the college that came from elsewhere
Trinity is the one of the four not founded in San Antonio. Cumberland Presbyterians established it in 1869 in Tehuacana, Texas, as a merger of three struggling colleges. It moved to Waxahachie in 1902 and to San Antonio in 1942, where its campus occupies a former quarry north of downtown. The grounds lie between the Monte Vista Historic District and the City of Olmos Park, so a Trinity student steps out onto streets of large early twentieth-century houses, worth knowing if you care about Monte Vista or Olmos Park Terrace.
The school's tie to its church is now a matter of history. A 1969 covenant with a synod of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) made it a private, independent university, and it remains a "historically connected" member of the Association of Presbyterian Colleges and Universities. The three other campuses are Catholic; Trinity's link to its founding church is a heritage and no longer a governing relationship. It is one of the two smallest of the four, with a total enrollment in the low thousands, and it competes in NCAA Division III, the division that does not offer athletic scholarships.
St. Mary's: the oldest Catholic university in Texas
St. Mary's began in 1852 as St. Mary's Institute, founded by the Society of Mary, the Marianists, and reference histories call it the oldest Catholic university in Texas and the Southwest. The campus is an urban one of about 135 acres. The St. Mary's University School of Law became part of the university in 1934 and moved to the main campus in 1967, so the city's private law school lives here. The Rattlers play in NCAA Division II in the Lone Star Conference.
St. Mary's has a seat on the city's calendar as well. The university hosts the Oyster Bake, held on campus every year since 1916 during Fiesta San Antonio in April, with concerts, food stalls and rides. The Fiesta Oyster Bake at St. Mary's University covers its history. For anyone wanting to know the university as a local institution, the Oyster Bake is the place to start, since it is the event that carries the campus into the city's calendar.
Our Lady of the Lake: a small campus with a long Catholic tradition
Our Lady of the Lake was founded in 1895 as the Academy of Our Lady of the Lake by the Sisters of Divine Providence, a religious institute that began in Lorraine, France. It is a Catholic university sponsored by the Texas congregation of the Sisters of Divine Providence, with a main campus of about 72 acres. It also has satellite campuses in The Woodlands and in La Feria in the Rio Grande Valley, which sets it apart: it is the one of the four that has built a presence outside San Antonio. It is the smallest of the four in acreage and, by recent figures, close to Trinity in total enrollment, around two thousand students. It competes in NAIA, mainly in the Red River Athletic Conference.
Reference histories also list notable alumni and faculty with ties to the city's Mexican-American community, and record that a dozen majors, including Mexican-American studies, were cut in 2013, a decision some saw as at odds with the school's mission. Debates of that kind are common at small private universities, and they are a reminder that each campus has its own politics along with its own architecture.
Incarnate Word: the biggest of the four
The University of the Incarnate Word was founded in 1881 as the Incarnate Word School by the Sisters of Charity of the Incarnate Word, and the sisters still hold a religious affiliation with it. It is described as the largest Catholic university in Texas, with an enrollment of more than 9,000 in fall 2025, roughly twice the size of the next largest of the four. Its main campus is in the Midtown Brackenridge area, in and around the enclave city of Alamo Heights, among the neighborhoods described in Alamo Heights.
It also has the broadest set of professional programs of the four. The Feik School of Pharmacy, the UIW School of Osteopathic Medicine and the Rosenberg School of Optometry are among its schools, and it competes in NCAA Division I, with football at the FCS level in the Southland Conference. A student weighing a health-science degree on a private campus should look closely at these schools.
What the four share
Three things hold across the group.
- Religious founding. All four began as projects of religious bodies, three Catholic orders and one Presbyterian denomination. Only Trinity has loosened the tie into a historical connection; the others remain Catholic institutions.
- A convenient scale. All four are small or mid-sized by university standards. A student at any of them is likely to know faculty by name, which is the case made for small private campuses everywhere.
- Urban settings. Each campus is within the city or its enclaves. Students without a car should check the VIA system map for each campus; Getting around downtown San Antonio without a car explains the transit basics.
Where they differ
The contrasts are as useful as the likenesses. Trinity is a university with a quarry-site campus and a Division III athletic program. St. Mary's is a Marianist campus with a law school and a Fiesta tradition. Our Lady of the Lake is a small Catholic campus with satellites. Incarnate Word is the biggest, with health-science schools and Division I athletics. A student choosing among them is really choosing among four missions.
Questions worth carrying to a campus visit
The four are alike in some ways and unlike in others, so a visit goes further with specific questions in hand.
- For Trinity: What does the school's historic Presbyterian connection mean in daily campus life now? How do students use the neighborhoods next door, Monte Vista and Olmos Park, for housing and internships?
- For St. Mary's: How does the law school relate to the undergraduate campus? How involved are students in the Oyster Bake and other Fiesta events?
- For Our Lady of the Lake: What do the satellite campuses in The Woodlands and La Feria offer, and which programs are taught where? How has the program list changed since the cuts of 2013?
- For Incarnate Word: How do the health-science schools admit and place students? What does Division I athletics mean for campus life and for the school's schedule?
- For all four: What is the net price after aid for a student like you, not the sticker price? What share of students graduate in four years? What happens to a student who changes majors?
An admissions office can answer each of those in writing. A student who puts the same list to all four schools will learn more than one who takes the brochures at face value.
Where the campuses meet the city
The four campuses neighbor the city's major institutions. Trinity's neighbors include Monte Vista and the City of Olmos Park. Incarnate Word's Broadway campus lies in the Midtown Brackenridge area; Brackenridge Park and the Garden District covers the park district nearby. A San Antonian who has never set foot on a campus can check each school's public calendar for lectures, concerts and games open to visitors.
How to choose, and where to look
Treat this list as the start of a search. The schools' own pages list current tuition, financial aid, programs and admissions requirements, and the federal government's College Navigator tool offers comparable data on every institution. The city's public Alamo Colleges District is a different kind of option, a five-college community college system that also sends transfer students to these campuses; The Alamo Colleges' five campuses explains it. For a broader overview that includes the public universities, see Choosing a college in San Antonio: Alamo Colleges, UTSA and the privates and UTSA and UT Health San Antonio: two campuses, one university. And for the public body that connects them all, Alamo Colleges District profiles the district.