Blog
The 20,000-signature route to amending the San Antonio charter
How a change to San Antonio's city charter reaches the ballot, by council ordinance or a 20,000-signature petition, with the 2024 amendments as the example.
The City Attorney's page for the charter puts it in one phrase: the constitution of the City of San Antonio. It is the text that says the city has a council and a city manager, how long council members serve, who can be recalled and how the ethics rules are enforced. The ordinances the council passes on a Thursday morning cannot override it. Changing it takes a vote of the people.
Every time someone is angry about a council decision, the same question comes up. Can residents change the charter themselves, without waiting for the council to agree? The city's own page says yes, with a number attached. State law lets the public put a proposed charter amendment before San Antonio voters if it carries at least 20,000 signatures from qualified city voters. Here is that route, the council's own route, and what the latest round of amendments looked like.
What the charter is, and where to read it
San Antonio adopted its current charter in 1951, and it made the city a council-manager government: voters elect a council and a mayor, and the council hires a professional city manager to run the departments. An elected Charter Commission chaired by Walter W. McAllister wrote it. It has been amended many times since, and the changes are woven into the current text rather than listed separately.
The full charter sits on Municode, the online code library the city uses for its code of ordinances. To learn what a section says today, read it there. The City Attorney's charter page at sa.gov links to it. To learn what it said in a given year, start with the City Clerk, who keeps the city's municipal archives and records (see Office of the City Clerk).
Two doors to the ballot
There are two, and the 2024 amendments came through the first.
Door one: the council and its commission. The city's Charter Review Commission, which the City Attorney's page describes as the body that "reviews and updates changes to the City Charter," studies the document. What actually goes on a city ballot is set by a council ordinance. The City Attorney's page links to the one for the 2024 cycle, Ordinance 2024-08-08-0550, labeled as the charter election ordinance. For its contents, read the ordinance itself.
Door two: residents petition. State law, as the City Attorney's page summarizes it, lets the public submit a proposed amendment to the voters with at least 20,000 signatures from qualified city voters. "Qualified" matters. A signature counts only if the signer is a registered voter living inside the city limits, which is why an address and a registration check are part of any petition drive. The city's petitions page, linked from the charter page, posts the filing requirements.
The City Attorney's page gives one number, 20,000. The deadlines, the petition format, the rules for who may circulate it and how long signature verification takes are on the petitions page and in state law. Those are the details that sink petition drives, so read them before gathering a single signature, not after.
What the 2024 amendments show
On November 5, 2024, San Antonio voters faced six charter questions, and all six passed. Together they make a handy tour of what the charter controls:
| Proposition | What it did | Result (approximate) |
|---|---|---|
| A | Changed the Ethics Review Board | about 72% yes |
| B | Modernized charter language | about 68% yes |
| C | Removed the 2018 caps on the city manager's pay and tenure | about 54% yes |
| D | Lifted the long-standing ban on off-duty political activity by city employees | about 63% yes |
| E | Set new pay for the mayor and council members | about 64% yes |
| F | Four-year council terms with a two-term limit | about 53% yes |
The percentages are the ones reported in the days after the election. On the closest propositions, C and F, a few points moved the outcome. For what each amendment did in practice, see How four-year terms reset San Antonio's election calendar, Proposition C and the end of the city manager pay cap and What San Antonio's council members and mayor are paid after Proposition E.
Two of the six show how amendments get contested. Supporters of Proposition F said longer terms give members time to learn the job and cut the number of campaign seasons. Opponents said voters should not be stuck for four years with a representative they disagree with. Proposition C split the council's supporters from its critics another way. Supporters said the council needs the power to appoint, remove and recruit a manager on its own terms. Opponents said the manager should still face term limits and that the money would be better spent raising the lowest city salaries.
The petition arithmetic
Imagine a group of residents who want to propose an amendment. They need 20,000 valid signatures. Experienced petition organizers know that not every signature a volunteer collects will count: some signers are not registered, some live outside the city limits, some sign twice, and some signatures cannot be read. Say a drive finds that four in five survive verification. Then the group has to collect 25,000 to end up with 20,000 valid ones, since 20,000 divided by 0.8 is 25,000. That 80 percent is a hypothetical, not a San Antonio statistic. The point is only that the target to aim for sits above the number in the law, and the margin of safety is the group's planning decision.
Timing is a second problem. A petition that qualifies still has to land on an election, and the dates available for city elections have moved. The council voted on December 18, 2025 to shift the city's May elections to November of odd-numbered years, and the next council and mayoral election is in 2029 (see Why the council voted 6-5 to move city elections from May to November). Which election day a petition lands on is the City Clerk's and the council's question, and any group should ask the clerk early.
Three things the 2024 votes changed, up close
A table hides how specific charter language gets. Three of the six touch things residents notice.
Pay. Before Proposition E, council members earned $45,722 a year and the mayor $61,725, figures set in 2015. The amendment set council pay at $70,200 and the mayor's at $87,800, and tied future adjustments to the HUD median income for a four-person San Antonio household, so the numbers move every year without another vote. The details, including the arguments over a raise of roughly $25,000 and the fact that members may decline pay, are in What San Antonio's council members and mayor are paid after Proposition E.
Off-duty politics. Proposition D lifted a ban on off-duty political activity by city employees that had stood for 72 years. Whatever one thinks of it, it shows how long a charter provision can last when nobody has the votes or the petition to change it. A rule written for one era's worries stayed in force across more than seven decades of city politics.
The Ethics Review Board. The board is an 11-member citizen body that enforces the city's ethics, lobbying and municipal campaign finance rules. Proposition A changed how it works. Because it was a charter amendment, it needed an election, where a change to an ordinary city rule would have needed only a council vote (see Ethics Review Board).
Questions people ask
Can the council amend the charter by itself? No. A charter change needs a vote of the city's voters. The council decides what to put on the ballot, and the voters decide whether to adopt it.
Where do I find the exact language that voters saw? The ordinance calling the election and the ballot language are public records. The City Clerk keeps them, and the city's open records portal handles requests for anything not already online (see how to request public records from the city and county).
Practical steps for a resident
- Read the section you want to change. Open the charter on Municode and read the current text. A proposal that duplicates an existing sentence or contradicts another section will draw a legal objection before it draws a vote.
- Check whether the council or the Charter Review Commission has already taken it up. The City Attorney's page lists the commission, and agendas for its meetings and for council are posted on SASpeakUp (see A Thursday A Session, item by item for how to read one). If the council is already preparing the same change, speaking at a meeting is cheaper than a petition drive (see How to speak at a San Antonio City Council meeting).
- Confirm your signers can vote in the city. A neighbor who lives in Alamo Heights or Castle Hills is a Bexar County voter but not a San Antonio voter, because those cities are independent (see Alamo Heights, Olmos Park and the independent cities inside San Antonio). The city's district map will tell you a council district (see how to find your council district and representative).
- Read the petitions page and ask the City Clerk's office to confirm the current requirements. The charter page points to the petitions page, and anything you are unsure of is worth asking for in writing.
- Plan for legal review. The City Attorney's office advises the council, and any amendment that reaches the ballot has gone through the city's legal process.
This is general information about how the process works, not legal advice. The charter, the state statutes behind it and the City Clerk's instructions are the authorities, and a group serious about a petition should consult them directly, and probably a lawyer.
Where the record lives
The Bexar County Elections Department runs city elections under contract with the City Clerk, and it certifies and posts the results of charter votes. Registration for the next election closes 30 days before it, and the Secretary of State's site handles the form (see how to register to vote and find your polling place). A list of every recent measure that reached the ballot, with results, is in The San Antonio ballot measures of 2024 through 2026, in order.