Blog
Proposition C and the end of the city manager pay cap
Voters capped the city manager's pay and tenure in 2018 and lifted both caps in 2024 with about 54% yes. The arithmetic and the arguments.
San Antonio voters were asked the same question twice in six years, and they gave opposite answers. In 2018 they limited what the city manager could be paid and how long the manager could stay. In November 2024 they took the limits out. Proposition C passed with about 54 percent in favor and gave the question of the manager's pay and tenure back to the city council.
The episode is a tidy lesson in how a council-manager city divides power. It also shows how a quarrel over one salary can turn into a quarrel over labor relations, accountability and who gets to hire the person who runs the departments.
Why the manager matters
San Antonio runs on the council-manager form. The City Attorney's page says the city adopted its current charter in 1951, and that charter made the city a council-manager government. Under it the elected council sets policy and the manager runs the organization. The council appoints the manager and can remove the manager. The mayor, elected citywide, presides over the council and votes with it, but day-to-day administration belongs to the manager's office.
The reach is long. The City Manager's Office oversees the departments on the city's website, which counts 45 departments and offices, from Police and Fire to Solid Waste, Public Works and Metro Health. The manager also prepares the budget the council votes on each year; the adopted fiscal 2027 budget is $4.41 billion across all funds. The job is described further in what a city manager does in a council-manager city, and the record sits at City Manager's Office.
A post with that much authority makes the questions of pay and tenure matter. That is why the charter's limits drew the attention they did.
The 2018 limits
In 2018, voters approved two limits on the city manager position:
- A pay cap. The manager's salary could be no more than ten times the pay of the lowest-paid salaried city employee.
- A tenure cap. The manager could serve no more than eight years.
The margin was wide. The campaign was pushed by the San Antonio Professional Firefighters Association during a contract fight with the city manager of the time. The pay cap worked by a specific mechanism: it chained the top salary to the bottom one.
How the formula works
The ten-times rule is a ratio, and a ratio is worth working through.
Say the lowest-paid salaried employee earns $37,000 a year. That figure is hypothetical, chosen to show the arithmetic. Ten times it is $370,000, and that is the cap on the manager's pay. A 2024 voter guide put the cap at about $370,000 for the manager at that time, so the example lands in the right range.
Now say the city lifts its lowest-paid salaried workers by $1,000. The cap rises by $10,000. Every dollar added to the floor raises the ceiling by ten.
That linkage was the heart of the opponents' case against Proposition C in 2024. If the city wanted to pay its manager more, they said, the honest route under the 2018 rule was to raise the pay of the lowest-paid employees first. The rule bound the two numbers together.
The tenure cap is simpler. A manager who began in a given year could serve until eight years later and no further. After that the charter required a successor, whatever the council wanted.
What Proposition C did
Proposition C was one of six charter amendments on the November 5, 2024 ballot, and all six passed. Its text asked voters whether to "grant to City Council the authority to set the full terms" of the city manager's employment, tenure and compensation included. Put plainly, it removed both caps. Now the council sets the manager's pay and decides how long the manager serves, through the same appointment-and-removal power it already held. About 54 percent said yes, a close vote next to the other amendments on that ballot, which passed by larger margins.
The ballot also carried Proposition F on council terms and Proposition D on off-duty political activity by city workers. The 20,000-signature route to amending the San Antonio charter has the full list. Proposition C shared the ballot with them, but the argument over it stood apart.
The case for removing the caps
Supporters, as the voter guides summarized them, made three points.
- The council appoints and removes the manager, so it should set the terms. A body that can hire and fire already holds the most direct control there is. Supporters saw no reason to hold back the other levers, pay and tenure.
- An eight-year clock makes hiring harder. The voter guide noted that some council members warned that qualified candidates might shy away from a job with a built-in end date. That worried them in particular for finding a successor when the then-current manager's term reached its limit in 2027. A candidate who must leave another job for a post that lasts eight years at most is being asked to accept a cliff.
- Recruiting is the council's job. If the council has to find, hire and keep a manager, supporters said, it needs the tools to make an offer. No comparison with other cities' salaries is offered here.
The case for keeping them
Opponents argued otherwise.
- The manager is the most powerful administrative official in the city and should face limits, as elected officials do. The mayor and council have term limits. A position of comparable influence, the argument went, ought to have something similar.
- Raise the bottom, not the top. As the arithmetic above shows, opponents said that if the city wanted a higher salary for the manager it should raise pay for its lowest-paid employees, which lifts the cap through the ratio. That framed the issue as fairness inside the city workforce.
- The firefighters' union opposed the change. Its position follows from its part in the 2018 campaign. The union that pushed the limits in 2018 argued against taking them out.
Beneath the dispute lies one point of agreement. Both sides accept that the manager's pay and tenure matter. They differ on who should hold the pen: the voters, through a charter rule, or the council, through the ordinary business of appointment and budgeting.
What changed in practice
The charter change moved the decisions to the council, so after November 2024 the visible questions are three.
- What does the council decide on pay? The council's votes are public, and the manager's compensation is now part of what the council can set. It shows up in the city's budget documents and on council agendas. Check the City Clerk's agenda postings and the budget book rather than a secondhand number.
- What does the council decide on tenure? With no eight-year ceiling, a manager serves as long as the council's votes keep the manager in the job. That is a political fact as much as a legal one: a council that can remove a manager can also decline to renew an arrangement.
- How does the timing line up with elections? Council members now serve four-year terms, after voters approved Proposition F in the same election. So the body that appoints the manager is itself on a longer cycle. How four-year terms reset San Antonio's election calendar takes up the effects.
The combination deserves a second look. A council with four-year terms and the power to set the manager's terms has more say over the shape of city government than a council with two-year terms and a capped manager. Whether that is good or bad depends on what one expects of the council.
Where to read the primary documents
A reader who wants to check the details has several places to go:
- The charter itself, posted on Municode and described on the City Attorney's charter page, which also explains how charter amendments reach the ballot (a petition of at least 20,000 qualified city voters, or a council ordinance).
- The City Manager's Office page on sa.gov, which lists the deputy city manager and assistant city managers.
- The adopted budget at sa.gov, for the numbers the manager's office works with. How to read the San Antonio city budget is a general guide to reading it.
- The council's posted agendas on SASpeakUp, where any item about the manager's contract would appear 72 hours or more before a meeting.
For the budget itself, see Inside the $4.41 billion FY 2027 budget, which covers the $4.41 billion plan the manager's office produced for the fiscal year that began October 1, 2026.
Why it is worth remembering
The Proposition C story flattens easily into a headline: "voters remove cap on city manager's pay." The longer version shows a city adjusting its own rules after living with them. In 2018 a labor dispute led voters to put a ceiling on the city's top pay and tenure. In 2024 the same voters, in a different year and a different mood, took the ceiling off, by a margin close enough that nobody could claim a mandate.
Both votes are public record. Both rested on arguments with real force behind them, and no fact about the budget settles either. A reader who wants to form a view has the materials: the ratio, the eight-year limit, the council's power to hire and fire, and the question of who should set the terms. What remains is a judgment about how far to trust an elected council with a decision that voters once took away.