Blog

Cinco de Mayo and Diez y Seis in San Antonio

Questions and answers on what Cinco de Mayo and Diez y Seis commemorate, why they are confused and how San Antonio's history connects to both.

Every May and every September somebody at the table asks it. Which one is Independence Day? Why does the city make a fuss over both? Where do we go? They are fair questions, since even people who celebrate both days mix them up. Here are the answers one at a time, with the record behind each and a plain word where the record stops.

San Antonio is the right place to ask. The city sat inside Spain's empire, then inside Mexico, before it ever belonged to Texas, and its people have come from both sides of the river for three centuries. These holidays did not arrive here by import.

What does Cinco de Mayo commemorate?

May 5. Mexico's victory over French forces at the Battle of Puebla on May 5, 1862, a fight led by General Ignacio Zaragoza. The win was real and it was not final. In 1863 a larger French force beat the Mexican army at the Second Battle of Puebla and took Mexico City, and Emperor Maximilian I ruled from 1864 to 1867. After the U.S. Civil War, France pulled out its troops, and Maximilian was executed.

So the holiday remembers one battle in a long war, not the end of it. That explains why it is not a national holiday in Mexico. According to a reference summary, public schools close nationwide on May 5, the day is an official holiday in the state of Puebla and a full holiday in neighboring Veracruz, and elsewhere in Mexico the observance is mostly ceremonial.

Is Cinco de Mayo Mexican Independence Day?

No, and this is the mix-up everybody makes. Mexican Independence Day is September 16. It marks the start of the Mexican War of Independence in 1810, when the priest Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla called for rebellion against the Spanish Empire, the Grito de Dolores, or Cry of Dolores. The reference summary says independence was finished later, when the Army of the Three Guarantees entered Mexico City on September 27, 1821.

Cinco de Mayo falls 52 years after the Grito and about 41 years after independence was won, in a different war against a different empire. (1862 minus 1810 is 52; 1862 minus 1821 is 41.)

What is "Diez y Seis"?

Diez y Seis is Spanish for "ten and six," the sixteenth, and San Antonio uses it as the name for the September 16 celebration. The full name is Diez y Seis de Septiembre. In Mexico the ceremonial center is the capital: around 11 p.m. on September 15, the president rings the bell Hidalgo rang in 1810 and recites the Grito, finishing with "Viva Mexico!", and a military parade follows the next morning. Governors, local officials, embassies and consulates hold similar ceremonies on September 15 or 16, according to the same summary.

In the United States, the summary says, Independence Day is also celebrated in states with large Mexican-heritage populations. It names no states, and it does not mention Texas or San Antonio. The San Antonio events are covered in the city's own calendar.

What is the connection between San Antonio and Mexican independence?

A direct one, and it does not depend on any holiday. According to the Texas State Historical Association's timeline of San Antonio, republican forces captured the city on April 1, 1813, and the Battle of the Medina crushed the rebellion on August 18, 1813. Those events belong to the independence struggle in which Spanish authority was challenged across New Spain, and San Antonio was caught in it eight years before independence came in 1821.

In 1836 the story turned. Texas Revolution events, from the siege in 1835 (The siege of Bexar, October to December 1835) to the Alamo (The Alamo, February 23 to March 6, 1836), put the city on the other side of a new dispute with Mexico. Tejano volunteers fought on the Texan side, and the history is more tangled than one flag. For a San Antonian of Mexican descent, the holidays acknowledge a heritage that runs through all of it.

Where does San Antonio celebrate Cinco de Mayo?

The best-known address is Market Square. A reference summary calls it the largest Mexican market in the United States, a three-block outdoor plaza downtown, and says it hosts the Cinco de Mayo celebration in central San Antonio along with many other fiestas through the year. The El Mercado building was a Works Progress Administration project finished in 1938 to 1939 and first called the Municipal Truck Market, because farmers sold produce off their trucks. The last produce was sold there in 1975, and the building became an enclosed, air-conditioned market. See Market Square for the district and A food walk through Market Square and the old plazas for a walk through it.

The city's topic list also ties the holidays to other venues, among them La Villita, the historic arts village by the river. Programs at each venue change from year to year, and organizers publish and revise dates, so check the venue's calendar before building a plan around one event.

Where does San Antonio celebrate Diez y Seis?

The city's topic list pairs the Diez y Seis holiday with the Rock 'n' Roll marathon weekend in a single topic. That says how the events are indexed and nothing about where they happen. Market Square, which hosts many fiestas through the year, is a reasonable place to start looking, and the district's and the city's calendars list what is scheduled in a given year.

Are these official city holidays?

The City of San Antonio's 311 service lists hours for city holidays, with reduced hours from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Each department sets which days its office observes, so anyone who needs to know whether a city office is open on a given day should check the department's page or call 3-1-1.

Is it all about food and drink?

There is a commercial side. In the United States, according to the reference summary, Cinco de Mayo grew in the 1980s, when beer, wine and tequila companies promoted it, and a market-research firm reported that more beer was bought for Cinco de Mayo in 2013 than for the Super Bowl or St. Patrick's Day. In 2005 Congress passed a resolution calling on the president to issue a proclamation for the day.

Celebration in the U.S. began earlier, among Mexican communities in California in the 1860s. The summary cites a 1862 celebration in Columbia, California, and says the holiday has been observed there continuously since 1863. So the American version is older than its marketing, and it began as a way for Mexican Americans to mark a victory.

San Antonio's food calendar, which counts the Mexican-heritage holidays among its events, is in A year of San Antonio food events. The city's Mexican food traditions, from the chili queens of Military Plaza to Tex-Mex, are in What Tex-Mex means in San Antonio, and what Tex-Next adds and The chili queens of Military Plaza.

Why does it matter in a Texas city?

Start with the Spanish-language media. Raoul Cortez launched KCOR, a Spanish-language radio station, in 1946, and KCOR-TV in 1955, the nation's first Spanish-language television station, according to the Texas State Historical Association. La Prensa, a Spanish-language newspaper, was founded in 1913. They are part of why cultural holidays here have an audience and an institutional memory. See La Prensa, KCOR and Spanish-language media.

The festival calendar as a whole, from Fiesta to Dia de los Muertos, is in A year of San Antonio festivals, from the February rodeo to the winter bowl and Luminaria and Dia de los Muertos, the fall calendar.

Do the two holidays mean the same thing to everyone?

No, and nobody should assume so. For some families the days are about heritage, for others about community and food, and for some mostly a day off or an excuse for a party. Meaning changes from household to household, and no single account speaks for all San Antonians.

What the record does show is two different anniversaries with two different histories. Cinco de Mayo remembers a single victory in a war Mexico had not yet won. Diez y Seis remembers a call to rebellion that began a war eleven years long, from 1810 to independence in 1821. Anyone who knows the difference can read the programs for each day: ceremonies tied to independence on September 15 and 16, observances tied to the Battle of Puebla on May 5.

A timeline for the two holidays

Year Event
1810 Miguel Hidalgo calls for rebellion (the Grito de Dolores), commemorated September 16
1813 Republican forces capture San Antonio on April 1; Battle of the Medina on August 18
1821 Army of the Three Guarantees enters Mexico City on September 27
1836 Texas Revolution; the Alamo falls on March 6
1862 Battle of Puebla on May 5
1863 Larger French force defeats the Mexican army at the Second Battle of Puebla
1946 KCOR, a Spanish-language radio station, launched in San Antonio
1955 KCOR-TV, the nation's first Spanish-language television station

Look down the left column. Most of the holidays' history happened before Texas was a state. San Antonio's own part, in 1813 and 1836, is why the city has a stake in the story of Mexican independence beyond the cultural one.

How should a visitor plan?

  1. Know the dates. Cinco de Mayo is May 5 and Diez y Seis is September 16.
  2. Check the organizers. Dates and programs change each year. Look at the venue's and the city's calendars.
  3. Expect crowds downtown. Market Square events pack people into a compact area; check VIA service alerts and DriveTexas, and see Riding VIA: fares, passes and transfers.
  4. Mind the weather. May and September in San Antonio are warm. The National Weather Service normals give an average high of 86.6 degrees in May, with 4.40 inches of precipitation on average, the wettest of the months listed in the city's climate normals used here.
  5. Do not assume. If a friend calls May 5 "Mexican Independence Day," the polite correction is September 16.

Two holidays, two wars, two centuries. A city that celebrates both has a better claim than most to knowing the difference.

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic