Blog

The chili queens of Military Plaza

Mexican American women fed San Antonio from open-air plaza stands until city leaders pushed them out. What the record says and where the dates disagree.

When the sun went down in the late nineteenth century, the plazas of downtown San Antonio became open-air dining rooms. Women set up tables and cooking fires on Military Plaza, in front of the Alamo and at Market Square, and sold chili con carne, tamales and enchiladas to whoever walked up: soldiers, merchants, tourists, writers. They were the chili queens. They are among the most famous people in the city's food history and among the least documented, because the women who made the food left few written records, and by most accounts the recipes were never written down.

Who they were

The chili queens were, in the words of a San Antonio Report article on their history, nineteenth-century Mexican American women, working-class and enterprising, who built food communities in public plazas and markets. A reference article on chili con carne makes the same point more broadly, saying that chili largely originated with working-class Tejana and Mexican women, and that San Antonio's chili queens sold cheap chili beef stew in casual chili joints.

What the record describes is a business and not a costume. The women bought ingredients, cooked on the spot, kept their own recipes and served a regular clientele, often at night, in the open air. The Texas State Historical Association's history of the city says it plainly: chili queens served chili con carne, tamales and enchiladas at night from stands in Alamo Plaza, Market Square and other places.

The recipes were a trade secret. The San Antonio Report article says they were generally kept secret and gives one well-known example: a woman who sold chili at a baratillo, a small open-air market, near what is now Market Square in the 1920s and 1930s never wrote her recipe down.

Where they worked

The plazas are the heart of the story, and the places are still there.

  • Military Plaza. It sits in front of City Hall, on the site where the presidio was relocated in 1722. The city's chili-queen tradition is associated with it from the 1880s.
  • Alamo Plaza. The writer O. Henry described nightly gatherings there in his 1904 story "The Enchanted Kiss," according to the San Antonio Report. The TSHA also notes that Stephen Crane and O. Henry both commented on the scene.
  • Market Square. The Mexican market district west of downtown is where the chili queens' tradition is most directly carried on, in a modern version, and where the older baratillo stood. The neighborhood is described in Market Square, and Market Square and the chili queens and A food walk through Market Square and the old plazas cover it street by street.

City food-history summaries usually put it this way: chili sold on Military Plaza from the 1880s and in front of the Alamo into the 1940s. The accounts do not all agree on the details, as the next section shows.

Where the dates disagree

A few dates in this story do not line up, and the honest way to tell it is to set them out.

  1. A start date. A city food-history summary places the chili queens on Military Plaza from the 1880s. The San Antonio Report article gives no starting year for the tradition, and the TSHA describes the women's night stands in the nineteenth century without pinning down a year.
  2. An end date. The San Antonio Report article says that in 1902 city leaders forcibly removed the chili queens from downtown plazas and mercados, citing sanitary reasons. Yet the same article describes a woman selling chili at the baratillo near Market Square in the 1920s and 1930s, and the city's food-history summary says chili queens were in front of the Alamo into the 1940s.
  3. How to reconcile them. The simplest reading is that the 1902 removal ended the plazas' status as the chili queens' regular home without ending the trade. Women kept selling in other places and under other arrangements, and the record is thin because the trade was informal. That reading is an interpretation and not a settled fact, and it should be treated as one.

The musician Lydia Mendoza is a useful marker of what came next. The San Antonio Report says she started singing alongside the chili queens on the Westside after the women had been pushed out of downtown. That suggests the tradition moved to the West Side instead of disappearing.

What the food was

The record is more exact about what was sold than about when. The TSHA lists chili con carne, tamales and enchiladas. The chili was the star. A reference article traces the dish's roots to Mexico, with chili-seasoned stews described in a 1529 account of Tenochtitlan, and says beef became the usual meat once Spanish colonists brought cattle to Mexico. The Spanish term "chile con carne" is first recorded in an 1857 book about the Mexican-American War.

The chili queens helped carry the dish out of the plazas. The reference article says San Antonio's tourism helped spread Texas-style chili across the South and West, and that a San Antonio chili stand at the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago gave many Americans their first taste of it. A few years after that exposition, in the late 1890s, William Gebhardt opened a factory to make chili powder and later sold it nationally, as the TSHA records; the story of that company and the German Texan kitchen that fed it is in William Gebhardt's chili powder and the German Texan kitchen. A chili queen's stand and a packaged powder are two ends of one tradition, a woman at a table and an industrial product. The packaged version could travel and the plaza version could not.

The state dish and what it left out

In 1977 the Texas Legislature made chili con carne the official state dish. The San Antonio Report notes that the resolution credited San Antonio but never mentioned the chili queens. The reference article gives the legislative vehicle as House Concurrent Resolution Number 18. So the dish has official recognition, and the women who made it famous are not named in the text that recognized it. That is the gap recent remembrance efforts try to fill, and it is the subject of Red chili, the 1977 resolution and the San Antonio claim: five myths sorted out.

How the tradition is remembered now

Several things keep the memory alive.

  • A forum in 2023. On September 21, 2023, the Main Plaza Conservancy hosted a forum on how to recognize the chili queens. According to the San Antonio Report, panelists and audience members suggested an annual fandango, a chili cook-off and a historical reenactment, and the fandango drew the most attention. The conservancy planned to collect oral histories.
  • Cook-off during Fiesta. A Chili Queens Cook-off is held at the Bonham Exchange during Fiesta, according to search summaries of the event. Fiesta itself, with its history from 1891, is described in fiesta from 1891 to today, a timeline.
  • Modern chili queens. Contemporary vendors appear at Market Square, and the city's food-history summary treats them as heirs of the original tradition.
  • A UNESCO case. When San Antonio was named a Creative City of Gastronomy in 2017, the city's chili heritage was one of the strands of its case, as How San Antonio became a UNESCO Creative City of Gastronomy explains.

Sanitary rules, then and now

The reason given for the 1902 removal was sanitation, and the word deserves a moment. Public health regulation of food is a legitimate job for a city, and every city that grew fast in the nineteenth century had to learn to do it. The chili queens' story does not raise the question of whether food should be inspected. It raises the question of how the rules were applied, and to whom. What is on record is the removal itself: it was forcible, and the stated reason was sanitary.

Today the job belongs to the San Antonio Metropolitan Health District, which inspects food establishments and issues food licenses, and the way a restaurant's inspection report works is covered in How San Antonio restaurant inspection reports work. Anyone who wants to open a food business in the city meets the same structure of licenses and permits, which Licensing a food business in San Antonio describes from the city's own department pages. Whether the plazas of 1902 would have been regulated differently, and whether the women could have complied, are questions the surviving record leaves open.

Reading a food legend carefully

A story like this attracts embellishment, so a few habits help.

  1. Separate the voices. Notice who is saying what. The women are mostly voiceless in the record, and what survives was written by observers, including famous writers whose accounts were colored by the time.
  2. Notice what is attributed. A date that shows up in one account and nowhere else deserves a raised eyebrow.
  3. Hold dates loosely when they come from different kinds of account. A newspaper article, a state history and a city's tourism summary have different standards.
  4. Look for the people. Names matter when they are known. The 2023 forum named several scholars and community members as participants, and the plan to collect oral histories is aimed at the problem of absent voices.
  5. Do not turn a tradition into a brand. The women sold food to make a living, and the history of their removal in 1902 is as much a part of the story as the nostalgia.

Where to go

The plazas themselves are free, and the free and low-cost guide at Free and low-cost things to do in San Antonio lists the downtown places worth seeing without paying admission. Market Square is the plaza with the most continuity, and Military Plaza, beside the city's own buildings, is where the story began. Stand there and you can read the history in the geography: the presidio's 1722 relocation, the nineteenth-century night market, the removal and the return. It is a short walk from one to the other, and it is the best way to see why a plate of chili is, in San Antonio, a piece of civic history.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic