Blog
Monte Vista: a walk through a district of many styles
Monte Vista began in 1889 on a goat pasture and was built block by block. How to read its mix of styles and what its two historic designations mean.
It started as a goat pasture. In 1889 real estate developers bought the ground about two miles north of downtown, and what grew there is now among the most architecturally varied neighborhoods in San Antonio. The variety comes from how it was built. Monte Vista was never laid out and constructed as a single project. Houses went up block by block, different developers owning different sections at different times, and building was largely finished by the 1930s. Four decades of fashion, from the late Victorian years into the early automobile age, ended up side by side.
That makes Monte Vista a good classroom for a skill useful all over town: reading a house. What follows gives the facts the public record supports, explains what the district's two historic designations mean, and offers a walk that doesn't depend on knowing any particular address.
What the record says
Monte Vista lies just north of the downtown core. It runs from the south, near San Antonio College and the area known as Ashby Place, up to its northern edge along Hildebrand Avenue, beside the independent City of Olmos Park. Development began in 1889, when real estate developers acquired the pasture, and homes were built block by block, largely finished by the 1930s.
The district carries two designations. It became a local historic district in 1975 and was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1998. The two dates deserve explaining, because many people use "historic district" for both and the effects differ.
Local designation: the one with design review
The City creates a local historic district. San Antonio lists 32, and Monte Vista is one. Inside a local district, changes to the exterior of buildings get reviewed. The Office of Historic Preservation staffs the Historic and Design Review Commission, and the office's pages list design guidelines and an application for proposed work. Own a house here and want to replace the windows, alter a porch, build an addition or demolish a structure? Call the Office of Historic Preservation at 210-207-0035 before any contractor starts.
National Register: recognition and incentives
The National Register of Historic Places is a federal list of properties worth preserving. Listing is a form of recognition and can open the door to preservation incentives, but by itself it does not impose the city's kind of design review on a private owner. That is general information about how the two systems usually work; for what applies to a given property, the Office of Historic Preservation and the Texas Historical Commission are the right sources. For Monte Vista the practical point is that the 1975 local designation governs what you can do to a house, and the 1998 listing shows the district's significance is recognized nationally.
The pasture, the grid and the lots
Look down on the district from above in 1890 and you would see a few houses on open ground. Look again in 1930 and you would see a nearly complete neighborhood. The change came in stages, and the stages explain what you see from the sidewalk.
Block by block. Because different developers owned different parts, each block has its own character. A block developed in one burst often has houses of similar age and scale, while a block filled in lot by lot shows a mixture. When the houses on one side of a street feel like a family and the other side doesn't, you are probably crossing a boundary between two sets of builders.
The gradient. As a rule, the earliest-built parts of any streetcar-era neighborhood lie nearest the city, where the first lots were sold. Here that would be the southern end near the college, with later additions filling in north toward Hildebrand. That is a general pattern and a guide for the eye, not a documented claim about specific blocks in Monte Vista.
The edges. The district's northern limit at Hildebrand Avenue meets the City of Olmos Park, a separate municipality. Olmos Park Terrace, north of Hildebrand, is its own local historic district beside the independent city. A walker crossing Hildebrand crosses a line that matters to the tax rolls, the police department and the school district. Why that is so is covered in Why a San Antonio address can mean one of a dozen school districts and Alamo Heights, Olmos Park and the independent cities inside San Antonio.
Reading the styles
The reference description of the surrounding historic area mentions French Eclectic, Neoclassical and Italian Renaissance houses. Those labels make a good vocabulary, and each has traits you can spot from the sidewalk.
- French Eclectic. Look for steep, hipped roofs, often with tall dormers that break the line of the eave. Chimneys are prominent, and some houses have a round or square tower near the front door. Windows are often tall and narrow, sometimes arched.
- Neoclassical. Look for columns, often two stories tall, holding up a front porch roof. The front tends to be symmetrical, with a central door and evenly spaced windows. Cornices and moldings use classical forms.
- Italian Renaissance. Look for low-pitched, tile-covered roofs, deep overhanging eaves, arched windows and doors, and wall surfaces of stucco or stone. The overall look is horizontal and calm.
You don't need the names to enjoy the contrast. A good habit: pick two neighboring houses and ask what each has that the other lacks. The answer is usually in the roof, the porch and the window shapes.
What the climate did to the design
San Antonio summers are hot, with average July highs of 94.9 degrees Fahrenheit and August highs of 96.0 in the National Weather Service's 1991 to 2020 normals. Houses built before air conditioning had to cope, and the features that did the work are still visible in the district: deep porches, tall ceilings and tall windows that could be opened top and bottom, trees planted for shade, and raised floors that let air move underneath. Walk Monte Vista in July and you feel the problem those features were designed to solve.
Walking it
An hour is enough for a good walk, and a few simple rules improve it.
- Start at the south end. San Antonio College is a landmark, and a transit stop or parking place near it is the natural place to begin. The Alamo Colleges, San Antonio College among them, are described in The Alamo Colleges' five campuses.
- Walk north and keep to the sidewalks. The district's northern boundary is Hildebrand Avenue, which gives you a natural turnaround point.
- Zigzag. Cross streets every block or two. The variation runs across the grid as much as along it.
- Look up. Roof lines, dormers and chimneys carry much of the character, and they are easy to miss if you look only at doors and porches.
- Respect private property. The houses are lived in. Stay on public sidewalks, keep your voice down and don't photograph people through windows.
In summer, bring water and walk early. In spring and fall the district's trees are at their best and the weather is why most San Antonians choose those seasons for a stroll. Seasons and what to wear in San Antonio describes the year.
When to go
The National Weather Service's 1991 to 2020 normals for San Antonio give a rough guide to the walking seasons. January averages a high of 63.3 degrees and a low of 41.0. February runs 67.5 and 45.1. April climbs to 80.3 and 58.4, and May to 86.6 and 66.4, with May the wetter month at 4.40 inches of rain. October, at 82.2 and 60.4, brings 3.75 inches. For an hour outdoors, the comfortable windows are late winter, April and the weeks from late October on; midsummer is a morning-only proposition. These are averages, and individual days vary widely, so check the forecast from the NWS Austin/San Antonio office before you go.
Rain is the other thing to plan around. Spring storms are a fixture of the San Antonio calendar, and walking shoes with good grip earn their keep.
Neighbors and the larger pattern
Monte Vista sits among other historic districts. The City's list includes Tobin Hill, Olmos Park Terrace, East French Place, Auditorium Circle and others nearby. Tobin Hill borders downtown and mixes residential, commercial and cultural uses. Alamo Heights is an independent city about two miles northeast of downtown, described as having the second-largest inventory of Victorian houses after King William. Walking from one to another shows how neighborhoods built within a few decades of each other still feel different.
That difference is what preservation tries to protect. The San Antonio Conservation Society was organized in 1924, a sign that the city's habit of saving its older buildings is nearly a century old. The City has since designated 32 local districts, and Monte Vista's designation dates to 1975.
If you own or are buying a house here
A few practical points, offered as general information and not advice.
- Check the status. The Office of Historic Preservation's Explorer Map shows the district boundary and which properties sit inside it.
- Ask before you build. Exterior changes in a local district generally require review. The building permit process is explained in How to get a building permit through BuildSA, and Office of Historic Preservation describes the preservation side.
- Budget for old houses. Houses built in the early twentieth century have their own maintenance needs. Costs vary with the house, so get estimates from local contractors who work on historic homes.
- Check property tax. The Bexar Appraisal District sets a house's taxable value, and the process for challenging it is in protesting your appraisal step by step.
The city's list of districts and the map are at the Office of Historic Preservation's page on sa.gov.