Blog

The San Antonio Arsenal and the secession winter of 1861

In February 1861 a general gave San Antonio's arsenal and $1.3 million in federal stores to Texas militia without a shot. The record and the site.

Nobody fired on the San Antonio arsenal. It changed hands at a table on February 16, 1861, after a few days of messages going back and forth. Brigadier General David E. Twiggs, commander of the U.S. Army's Department of Texas, gave up the arsenal and every other federal military installation in the state to Texas militia acting for the state's secession authorities. Nobody was killed. By the end of that week, the supplies stored in San Antonio belonged to a government that did not yet formally exist.

It is a short episode, and it goes a long way toward explaining why the arsenal ground is still a landmark and why a local historic district carries the name. It also shows how a quiet supply depot, built to outfit frontier forts, turned into a prize.

What the arsenal was for

The San Antonio Arsenal was founded in 1859. The Texas State Historical Association says it was established to supply arms and munitions to the Army's forts on the Texas frontier. San Antonio was already an Army town, with the Eighth Military Department headquarters here since 1848. A stockpile of muskets, pistols, cannon and powder that could be sent in any direction was just what the frontier needed.

Through the Civil War the arsenal was a 21-acre reservation. Keep that size in mind. It was a compound and not a fortress: storage and repair buildings, with no garrison able to hold off a determined force. In February 1861 that mattered.

A town of 8,235

Set the garrison against the city to get the scale. The 1860 census counted 8,235 people in San Antonio, the largest town in Texas. One hundred sixty soldiers, the number in the city at the surrender, is just under 2 percent of that (160 divided by 8,235 is about 1.9 percent). In a town that size they were a visible presence, enough to move the trade of the stores and boarding houses, and too few to hold the arsenal against a determined local force.

The Army's tie to the town was already more than a decade old. The war with Mexico, fought from 1846 to 1848, left a lasting U.S. military presence, and the Eighth Military Department's headquarters moved to San Antonio in 1848. The arsenal, founded in 1859, was the newest piece. How the Mexican War created what later became "Military City USA" is the subject of The Mexican War and the beginning of Military City USA and San Antonio in 1860: the largest town in Texas, which describe the same town a year or two before the secession winter.

The week of the surrender

The sequence is tight, so take it in order.

  • February 1, 1861: The Texas secession convention votes to leave the Union. The question goes to the voters.
  • February 15: Twiggs receives a War Department order relieving him of command. The surrender comes the next day.
  • February 16: Twiggs surrenders. According to Benjamin McCulloch's biography in the Handbook of Texas, McCulloch, commissioned a colonel and authorized to demand the surrender of federal posts, met Twiggs at the Alamo, and the encounter was bloodless. Twiggs handed over the arsenal and the other federal property in San Antonio.
  • February 23: Texas voters ratify secession in a statewide referendum.
  • March 1: The War Department dismisses Twiggs for what it calls "treachery to the flag of his country."
  • March 2: The date generally given for Texas's secession taking effect.

Mind the order. The surrender came after the convention voted but before the voters had ruled, and before secession was complete. Anyone who figures the property moved only after Texas was out of the Union has the sequence wrong. The militia moved first, on the word of a convention nobody had yet confirmed.

What was surrendered

The inventory shows the stakes. The surrender covered federal installations across Texas, the San Antonio arsenal among 20 military installations in all, according to the biography of Twiggs. The property was valued at $1.3 million and included 44 cannon, 400 pistols, 1,900 muskets, 500 wagons and 950 horses. Twiggs's command accounted for about 20 percent of the entire U.S. Army, because so much of the Army was posted along the Mexican border and the frontier.

There were 160 U.S. soldiers in San Antonio at the time, and they did not fight. Twiggs insisted on terms: the soldiers kept their personal arms, sidearms, flags and standards, and the garrisons in San Antonio and elsewhere were allowed to march out of Texas by way of the coast.

The terms show what each side valued. Texas got the stores and the posts without a battle. The Army commander got safe passage out of the state and let his men leave with their personal arms and flags. A bargain like that comes easier when one side is small, and only 160 soldiers were in the city.

The argument over Twiggs

The War Department dismissed him on March 1 for "treachery." He did not stay a federal officer for long in any case. He was commissioned a Confederate major general on May 22, 1861, then resigned because of poor health and retired on October 11 of that year.

Two readings remain open. In one, Twiggs gave way to a force he could not resist and saved lives. In the other, he chose a side and used his command to hand the stores to it. The question is unsettled, and this piece does not pretend otherwise. What stands firm is the sequence, the terms and the inventory.

Then there is San Antonio's own divided feeling. Not everyone in town welcomed secession. Dr. Anthony Dignowity, an abolitionist and Unionist who gave his name to a neighborhood, narrowly escaped hanging in the plaza in 1861 and left for Washington, a story told in Dignowity Hill: a walk on the Near East Side. The arsenal's surrender is the official side of that winter. His flight is the private one.

What happened to the grounds

The arsenal outlasted the Confederacy. During the war, Confederate forces occupied it and its supplies went to the Confederate war effort. When the war ended, the U.S. Army took the complex back and enlarged it over the next half century. By the end of World War I it had 38 buildings. In World War II it was a major supply depot and shipped more than 337,000,000 pounds of ammunition, the peak of its output.

The arsenal closed in 1949, though its buildings served as federal offices for years. In 1972, two acres and three buildings went to the City of San Antonio as parkland through the Bureau of Outdoor Recreation, and several other buildings were demolished. In 1985, H-E-B bought the remaining ten acres on the San Antonio River bank and remodeled the existing structures as its corporate headquarters. The grocery company's story is told in H-E-B: from a Kerrville kitchen grocery to a San Antonio institution.

The 21-acre wartime reservation shrinks to about twelve acres in the 1972 and 1985 accounts, a difference left unreconciled here. What is certain is that part of the old arsenal is now a city park and the rest houses a corporate headquarters, with a name that survives on the city's list of local historic districts.

Seeing it today

The city's Office of Historic Preservation lists Arsenal among its 32 local historic districts, with Alamo Plaza, Government Hill, King William and others. The office's list does not describe each district, but it points to an Explorer Map that shows boundaries. To see where the arsenal stood in relation to downtown, the map is the quickest route. The district lies along the San Antonio River.

Three reasons to go:

  1. The scale. Stand on the river bank and judge for yourself how small twenty-odd acres is, and how few men it would have taken to hold it or take it.
  2. The layers. The grounds have been a frontier supply depot, a Confederate store, a World War II ammunition hub, a federal office complex and a corporate campus. Few places in town have worn that many hats.
  3. The park. The two acres given to the city in 1972 are public land.

For the broader arc of how the city's federal presence began and changed, see The Arsenal and the H-E-B campus, and for the Army town that grew around it, Fort Sam Houston and Benjamin Foulois's first flight.

Reading the record carefully

The dates, quantities and terms above are drawn from the Texas State Historical Association's Handbook of Texas entries on the arsenal, Twiggs and McCulloch, and from the City's Office of Historic Preservation list. Those entries differ in how much detail they carry, and later retellings tend to add drama. Hold the sequence and the inventory firmly and the embroidery loosely.

Put the whole winter on one line and it reads like this: a convention votes, a general is relieved, a colonel arrives, a table is set, 160 soldiers walk out with their flags, and a depot full of cannon, muskets, wagons and horses changes owners before the voters have finished counting. That is a lot of consequence for a week with no casualties.

The lesson of the winter of 1861 is a modest one. Big events can turn on small, quiet transactions. The loss of $1.3 million in federal stores took no fighting at all. It took a general, a colonel, a table and a decision to avoid bloodshed. The place where it happened is now part park and part grocery company headquarters, which is a fair summary of how San Antonio treats its history: it keeps using the ground.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic