Blog

Dignowity Hill: a walk on the Near East Side

A historic district east of downtown is named for a doctor who barely escaped a hanging in 1861. How to walk it and how the city protects it.

Start with the man, because the neighborhood still wears his name and hardly anyone on its sidewalks knows his story. Anthony Michael Dignowity was born on January 16, 1810, in Kutná Hora, Bohemia, the tenth and last child of Wenzeslas and Catharine Dignowity. In 1832, to dodge the Austrian army's draft, he sailed from Hamburg for New York. Years later he reached San Antonio with a company of Arkansas volunteers bound for the Mexican War, stayed, and made himself a successful doctor and businessman. The hill east of downtown took his name.

He is also why a stroll through the district is more than an architecture tour. Dignowity was an outspoken abolitionist and Unionist in a Texas city heading the other way. In 1861, as the state left the Union, he narrowly escaped hanging in the plaza, rode a horse to Washington, D.C., and went to work for the federal government. His property was confiscated and two of his sons were conscripted into the Confederate army; the sons later escaped to Mexico and joined the Union side. He came back to Texas after the war in poor health and urged a Republican Congress to show moderation toward Southern "loyal residents." He died in San Antonio on April 22, 1875.

That biography, from the Texas State Historical Association, is the backdrop for the walk below. It is not a route with street names. The best guide to this district is the city's own map, and these notes are meant to be used alongside it.

The winter he left

The date of his flight matters. Dignowity's escape came in the same months the city's federal property changed hands. On February 16, 1861, the U.S. Army's commander in Texas surrendered the federal arsenal and other property in San Antonio to state authorities, weeks before Texas formally joined the Confederacy. The San Antonio Arsenal and the secession winter of 1861 tells that sequence. A reader who knows both stories sees one winter from two sides: a man leaving town to avoid a rope, and the town's military stores passing to a new government.

So the name on this district is more than a label. Many San Antonio neighborhoods carry the names of developers or of the streets they grew along. This one carries the name of a person who held an unpopular position and paid for it with his property, his sons' place in the Confederate ranks and years away from home. The Texas State Historical Association entry says his property was confiscated and that he returned only after the war. Whatever one makes of the details, the pattern is plain: an early resident of the hill was driven out for what he believed, and the neighborhood remembers him anyway.

Where it sits

Dignowity Hill is on the Near East Side, a short distance from downtown. It is one of 32 local historic districts listed by the City's Office of Historic Preservation, a list that also includes its neighbors St. Paul Square, Knob Hill and Government Hill. The city's page gives the list without describing each district, so for boundaries it points to the Office of Historic Preservation's interactive Explorer Map and to the office's number, 210-207-0035. Use that map before you go. It shows which parcels are inside the district and which are not, and it spares you from guessing where the boundary falls.

The neighbors help place it. St. Paul Square is a historic district on the Near East Side near the Alamodome. Cherry Street and Ellis Alley is an East Side corridor with its own history. Knob Hill is a separate historic district of Classical Revival homes, and Government Hill lies toward Fort Sam Houston. A walk that takes in the edge of two of them turns one district into a lesson in how the East Side grew in layers.

Stop one: the edge near downtown

Begin where the district meets the city's center. The view toward the downtown towers shows why this high ground was wanted: it looks over the older town. The Alamodome, which opened in 1993, is the big building in this part of town, and it frames how public projects reshaped the Near East Side through the twentieth century.

On this stretch, watch how the street grid shifts. Older neighborhoods grew block by block, not from one master plan, and the lot sizes vary. A narrow lot beside a wide one hints that the block was sold off in several pieces.

Stop two: the houses

The district's reputation rests on its old houses, and the useful way to look at them is by form instead of name. At each house, ask four questions:

  1. Where is the front door in relation to the street? Many older houses face the street with a porch that served as an outdoor room. A porch tells you the house predates air conditioning, when the shaded porch was the coolest place.
  2. What is the roof doing? Steep gables, hipped roofs and tall chimneys are common in late nineteenth-century houses. A flat addition at the back is usually newer.
  3. How are the windows set? Tall, narrow windows mark age. Replacement windows in a different proportion are among the most visible changes in historic districts, and the city's design review watches for them.
  4. What is the building made of? Wood frame, limestone and brick all show up in San Antonio's older neighborhoods. A limestone foundation under a frame house is common in the region.

These are ways of looking, not claims about any property. Individual houses go unnamed here, since the city's official description of the district names none, and addresses and dates for specific buildings are best taken from the Office of Historic Preservation's records.

Stop three: how the district is protected

A local historic district is a legal designation. Exterior changes to buildings inside it are reviewed. The city's Office of Historic Preservation staffs a body called the Historic and Design Review Commission, and the office's pages list the commission, a set of design guidelines and an application process for proposed work. The details of what needs approval are on the city's site, and an owner's best move is to ask the office before starting, not after.

Two practical points follow for anyone who lives in or near the district:

  • Ask first. Painting, siding, roofing, windows, porches and fences can all be affected. The rules differ by type of work, and the office can say which category a project falls in. Development Services handles permits generally; see Development Services Department for how that office works and Office of Historic Preservation for the preservation side.
  • Report problems the normal way. A vacant house with an open door, an overgrown lot or a dumped mattress is a 311 matter, and how to report a neighborhood problem: code, dumping and animals walks through the process. Historic districts get no special phone number for ordinary nuisances.

The city also recognizes a Historic Districts Coalition, the residents' group that brings together the neighborhoods carrying the designation. Its page on the city's website is the place to look for meetings.

Stop four: what happened to the East Side

No account of the Near East Side is complete without the twentieth century. Ellis Alley, part of the Cherry Street and Ellis Alley area, is described as one of the city's earliest African-American neighborhoods, and the East Side's story runs through segregation and its end. The city's parks, golf courses, buses, pools and train stations were desegregated between 1954 and 1956, lunch counters were integrated on March 16, 1960, and all public accommodations were desegregated on November 11, 1965. The longer story is in Desegregating San Antonio, 1954 to 1965.

Large public projects changed the area too, the Alamodome, opened in 1993, most visibly. Who bore the cost, and how many households were displaced, are questions with documented answers in other hands, so no blame is assigned and no counts given here. For that history, start with the Office of Historic Preservation and with neighborhood associations, which keep their own records.

Stop five: the part that is still changing

Lists of Near East Side neighborhoods often call Dignowity Hill "up and coming," a phrase that signals both investment and worry. Investment brings renovated houses and new construction. Worry comes from what rising values do to longtime residents and renters. San Antonio's property tax system, the appraisal process and the help the city offers against displacement are covered elsewhere: Displacement prevention and the Resident Relocation Assistance Program describes the city's approach, and protesting your appraisal step by step explains how an owner challenges a valuation.

A visitor can do something simple and useful here. Walk slowly, notice the mix of restored houses and ones that need work, and resist the urge to judge either. A district like this is a working neighborhood first and a historic one second. The good-guest rules are old ones: stay on public sidewalks, keep to the street, and treat porches and yards as the private spaces they are.

Before you go

A short checklist makes the walk better.

  • Open the Office of Historic Preservation's Explorer Map and look at the district boundary for the part you plan to walk.
  • Read the TSHA entry on Anthony Michael Dignowity first; it takes five minutes and changes how the name sounds.
  • Check VIA's trip planner for current bus service to the Near East Side, because routes change.
  • Bring water in summer. An hour's walk under San Antonio's sun is a real exposure, and Summer heat and SAWS water restrictions is a reminder of how seriously the city treats heat and water.
  • Be ready to learn something that is not on a plaque. Many of the most important buildings and stories in this district are not marked.

The official starting point is the city's Office of Historic Preservation, which maintains the list of districts and the map: sa.gov/Directory/Departments/OHP.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic