Blog

Knob Hill and its Classical Revival homes, myths and facts about historic districts

Myth versus fact on San Antonio's local historic districts, using Knob Hill, a district of Classical Revival homes approved in 2010.

Say "historic district" to a San Antonio homeowner and watch the face. Pride comes first, because the old houses are why anyone wants to live there. Dread follows close behind, because everybody knows somebody who supposedly couldn't paint a door. Knob Hill is a fair place to sort the porch-talk from the rulebook. It is one of the city's local historic districts, a stretch of Classical Revival homes approved in 2010, set among the historic corridors of the East Side. The Office of Historic Preservation publishes its rules in plain English, and they are a good deal less scary than the folklore. Below, the common myths, one at a time, each held up against what the office says.

One caution first. The city's pages lay out the framework in general terms. What applies to a particular house, meaning what counts as exterior work, which jobs need which review and what a district's own design standards say, depends on the property and the project. The city's advice is also the sensible advice: call the Office of Historic Preservation at 210-207-0035 before you start.

What Knob Hill is

Reference listings describe Knob Hill as a historic district of Classical Revival homes, approved in 2010. Classical Revival borrows from ancient Greece and Rome: symmetrical facades, columns or porticos, a formal bearing. On a residential street it produces houses that look as if they belong to one another. The city's districts page lists Knob Hill by style and date and leaves it there, so boundaries and individual houses are best taken up with the office. For the neighbors on this side of town, see Knob Hill, Dignowity Hill and St. Paul Square.

Knob Hill is one of 32 local historic districts in San Antonio, according to the city. They run from downtown plazas to residential neighborhoods like this one, and each has its own history. The city's districts page has the fact sheet for the whole set, and the neighborhood group that speaks for them is the Historic Districts Coalition, which the Office of Historic Preservation lists on its events page.

Myth 1: "A historic district means you can't change anything"

The fact. Designation doesn't freeze a property. The city says exterior work an owner chooses to do must be reviewed and approved by the Office of Historic Preservation, and that certain scopes of work, along with any work that doesn't fit the design guidelines, go to the Historic and Design Review Commission, the HDRC. Change is allowed. It just passes through a review, and the review asks whether the work fits the guidelines for that district.

Which jobs need review and which don't is spelled out on the office's design review pages. Replacing a roof, putting in windows, building a fence or adding a room: ask first.

Myth 2: "The city will make you restore your house"

The fact. Designation does not require owners to restore a property to its historic condition, the city says. No inspector arrives to ask that a porch go back to its 1910 form. The rules attach when you choose to do exterior work, and then they ask that the work be consistent with the guidelines. A house altered over the decades before designation isn't obliged to undo any of it because the street got a district.

Myth 3: "Designation changes what you can do with the property"

The fact. It doesn't change how a property may be used, the city says; zoning still governs use. A house zoned single-family stays single-family. A house in a mixed-use area stays in that area. Historic designation is a layer on top of zoning that deals with appearance and demolition, not with what goes on indoors.

The distinction matters to anyone weighing a business, a rental or an extra dwelling. What is allowed on a lot is a zoning question for the Development Services Department; see How to get a building permit through BuildSA and casitas: the city's accessory dwelling program. The historic question is separate, and it is about how the work looks.

Myth 4: "You can only paint your house certain colors"

The fact. Paint isn't limited by color, the city says. Requests are reviewed to confirm the material is appropriate for painting, and the office's own example is that painting historically unpainted brick or masonry is discouraged. The worry is the material, not the hue. Repainting wood siding a new color is one thing. Painting over a century-old brick facade is another, and the guidelines discourage it.

This is the myth that comes up most in neighborhood conversation, and the office's pages take it on directly.

Myth 5: "City Hall imposes a district on the neighborhood"

The fact. City Council adopts local districts by ordinance, but the process starts with the owners. The city says verified support from 51 percent of property owners is needed before the public hearing process begins, and that the process includes public input and final approval by the Council. A district is the end of something that began with the people who own the properties, not a decree.

That isn't the same as every owner agreeing. A district that passes with 51 percent in favor can still include owners who opposed it, and the rules then apply to them. Whether that is fair is the argument people in preservation fights have always had. The city's page shows the threshold and the steps, and the argument stays with the neighborhoods.

Myth 6: "A National Register district is the same thing"

The fact. The city draws the line itself: the 32 local historic districts are distinct from the 20 National Register historic districts in San Antonio. A National Register listing is federal recognition of a place's historic significance. A local district is a city designation, adopted by ordinance, with legally enforceable Historic Design Guidelines. A neighborhood can be in one, both or neither, and the review of exterior work comes with the local designation.

To learn which applies to a house, ask the Office of Historic Preservation. The two designations carry different consequences, and a house can be on the National Register without being subject to local design review.

Myth 7: "Designation protects a building forever"

The fact. Designation protects historic buildings from hasty demolition, the city says, and the word that matters is "hasty." It puts a review between an owner and the wrecking ball. Demolition becomes a decision that goes through a process, not a permit pulled on a Monday. Nothing promises a building can never come down. To see how a particular demolition request is handled, read the office's pages on pending cases and the HDRC's agendas.

That is the heart of what preservation law does: slow the loss of buildings that can't be replaced and give the public a say. It is also why the fight over districts is partly a fight over property rights. The owner of a designated building has agreed, or been asked to agree, to a review that a neighbor down the block doesn't face.

Myth 8: "Districts raise, or lower, your property value"

The fact. Nobody on the city's pages puts a figure on it, and it would be a mistake to claim either direction here. Both sides of the argument make confident claims about values in historic districts. Value depends on many things, and a reader after evidence should look for a study of the specific district, not a general claim. This article won't hand you a number it can't back.

How a review works in practice

Put the pieces together and an exterior project in a local district goes like this:

  1. You decide on a project. A window replacement, a new roof, a fence, an addition, new siding.
  2. You ask the Office of Historic Preservation. The office can tell you whether staff can approve the work or whether it needs the HDRC.
  3. Staff or commission review. Work consistent with the guidelines is typically handled by staff. Certain scopes, or work not consistent with the guidelines, go to the HDRC, which meets in public.
  4. You get your approval, then your permit. The building permit process runs through Development Services and its BuildSA system.
  5. You do the work.

The office's phone is 210-207-0035, and it sits at City Tower, 100 W. Houston St., open Monday through Friday from 7:45 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Customer service at 3-1-1 can route a question. The office's pages list an application portal, a list of pending cases and incentive programs; the incentive pages carry the particulars.

What Knob Hill shows

Knob Hill is what a district looks like when it works as intended: a recognizable set of houses in one style on one street, with owners who agreed to a process to keep it that way. A district approved in 2010 has had more than fifteen years of review under its guidelines, long enough for the myths to be tested. People still live there, repaint, fix their roofs and buy and sell. That is the best evidence that designation is no freeze.

For how San Antonio came to protect its old neighborhoods, starting with the Conservation Society organized in 1924, see The San Antonio Conservation Society, 1924 to today and Neighborhood groups and the Historic Districts Coalition. For the East Side's own history, Dignowity Hill: a walk on the Near East Side and St. Paul Square, where the railroad district meets the Alamodome cover the nearby neighborhoods, and Cherry Street and Ellis Alley: Black San Antonio on the East Side covers the corridor where some of the city's earliest African American neighborhoods grew. The office itself is profiled at Office of Historic Preservation.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic