Blog

What a city manager does in a council-manager city

San Antonio's mayor and council set direction while an appointed city manager runs the departments; the 1951 charter, who hires and fires, and how roles differ.

Ask ten San Antonians who runs the city and a fair number will point to the mayor. It is a sensible guess and a wrong one. San Antonio is a council-manager city. Voters elect a mayor and ten council members, but the person who hires and supervises the department heads and carries out the budget is the city manager, appointed by the council and answerable to it. From the sidewalk the arrangement is easy to miss: the manager is never on a ballot, and the mayor is on every newscast.

What follows takes the questions people ask most often, in the order they tend to come up. The answers draw on the City Attorney's charter page, the City Manager's Office page and the proposals that went before voters in November 2024.

Where does the manager's job come from?

From the city charter. San Antonio adopted its current charter in 1951, and with it the council-manager form, the document having been written by an elected charter commission chaired by Walter W. McAllister. (A state history places the adoption of the council-manager form in 1955; the City Attorney's page says 1951, and 1951 is the date used here.) The charter is posted on the Municode library, and changing it takes an election; the process is in The 20,000-signature route to amending the San Antonio charter.

The form splits one job into two. Elected officials decide what the city should do: the budget, the tax rate, the zoning cases, the ordinances. A professional administrator decides how to do it and manages the people who do. The thinking behind it is that running a large organization is a different skill from winning an election.

Who hires the manager, and who can remove one?

The council. The City Manager's Office page and the city's charter history describe the manager as the council's appointee, and the council can remove the manager. That is the hinge of the whole design: the manager works for an eleven-member body, the mayor included.

Until 2024 the charter put two limits on the post. The 2018 rules capped the manager's salary at ten times that of the lowest-paid salaried city employee and capped tenure at eight years. In November 2024 voters approved Proposition C, by about 54 percent, and both caps went away. Now the council sets the manager's pay and the length of service. The argument over it is in Proposition C and the end of the city manager pay cap. In brief, supporters said the council needs the power to appoint, remove and recruit a manager on its own terms, while opponents said the manager should face term limits and that the money would be better spent raising the lowest city salaries. The firefighters' union opposed Proposition C, according to the reporting after the election.

What does the manager actually do?

The manager is chief executive of the city's departments. In practice that comes to this:

  • Running the departments. The city site lists 45 departments and offices, from Police and Fire to Solid Waste, Parks, Libraries and the 311 customer service line. Department heads are appointed by the city manager unless the city's pages note otherwise.
  • Preparing the budget. The fiscal year 2027 budget, at $4.41 billion across all funds with a $1.76 billion General Fund, went to the council on September 17, 2026. The manager's staff builds the proposal; the council reviews and adopts it (see Inside the $4.41 billion FY 2027 budget).
  • Carrying out council decisions. When the council passes an ordinance on a street program or a housing bond, say, the manager's staff executes it.
  • Advising the council. Staff briefings happen at the Wednesday "B Session," where the council hears from the departments, generally without taking action (see Wednesday B Sessions: where council policy gets argued before it is voted).
  • Managing the day-to-day. A city of potholes and trash pickup is mostly a city of operations, and the manager's job is to see that the operations work.

The manager has help. As of 2026 the City Manager's Office lists a deputy city manager, a chief of financial and administrative services and five assistant city managers. The office is at City Hall, 100 Military Plaza, and the way into city services is the same as for any department: dial 3-1-1.

Who is the manager right now?

As of 2026 the City Manager's Office page names Erik Walsh as city manager. Since the council appoints and can remove the manager, the name can change. The title is the part that stays put.

How is the manager different from the mayor?

The mayor is elected citywide, presides over the council and votes on its measures. Under San Antonio's charter the mayor is not the chief administrator. The mayor's strengths lie in the council chair, in setting the tone of public debate, in speaking for the city to other governments and to business, and in the bully pulpit. As of 2026 the mayor is Gina Ortiz Jones, who took office in June 2025. The mayor's office is at City Hall and its phone line is 210-207-7107; the council office is 210-207-7040 (see Mayor's Office and San Antonio City Council).

Side by side:

Mayor City manager
How chosen Elected citywide Appointed by the council
Votes on ordinances Yes No
Runs the departments No Yes
Serves Four-year terms, two-term limit At the council's pleasure
Public role Presides, speaks for the city Administers, advises

Because the charter leaves daily administration to the manager, a mayor who wants a change usually gets it by persuading the council to pass an ordinance or fund a program, after which the manager's staff carries it out. That is also why a resident with a pothole gets further calling 3-1-1 than calling the mayor's office.

What does that mean for a resident with a problem?

It means the quickest route runs almost always through the department, not the elected official. The city's 311 service, at 3-1-1 or 210-207-6000, answers from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. every day and from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. on city holidays, and takes reports of potholes, graffiti, stray animals, overgrown yards and traffic signals. The full workflow is in what happens after you report a problem to 311. If a problem stays unsolved, council members hear about it, and the district council office (the city has ten single-member districts) is the next stop. The districts are covered in the ten council districts and how to find yours.

Does the manager get to make policy?

The manager makes recommendations, which is a quiet form of policy influence, and the council decides. The budget shows it best: the manager's office proposes, the council amends and adopts. That is why the budget is the council's biggest annual vote, and why the council holds no meetings in July, leaving staff the time to prepare it.

A hypothetical: from pothole to budget line

Say a resident reports a pothole on a neighborhood street. This illustrates how the pieces fit and is not a record of a real case.

  1. The resident calls 3-1-1 or uses the city's 311 portal. The request goes to the Public Works Department, which handles streets, sidewalks, drainage and potholes.
  2. If the pothole is one of many on the same street, a crew may patch it as routine work. If the street is failing, the repair becomes a question for the city's infrastructure program and capital budget.
  3. The capital budget, $1.4 billion of the $4.41 billion fiscal year 2027 budget, is built by the manager's staff and adopted by the council (see Inside the $4.41 billion FY 2027 budget). A street judged to need rebuilding has to compete for that money with other streets, drainage projects and buildings.
  4. If the resident is unhappy with the answer, the council member for the district hears the complaint, and the council can amend the budget.

At each step the person deciding changes. The crew answers to the department head, the department head to the manager, and the manager to the council. A resident who knows the chain can start at the right link.

Five common mix-ups

"The mayor is the city's boss." In a council-manager city the mayor presides over the council. The manager is the chief administrator.

"The manager is elected." The council appoints the manager and can remove one.

"The manager makes the rules." The manager recommends and carries out; the council adopts ordinances and the budget.

"The mayor and manager are the same office." They are separate offices with separate staffs, though both work out of City Hall.

"The manager has a term limit." Before November 2024 the charter capped the manager's tenure at eight years. Proposition C removed the cap, so the council now decides.

Why the charter chose this model

The council-manager form dates in San Antonio to the 1951 charter, written by an elected commission. It came in the same era as other changes in how the city worked; one landmark of the period was Henry B. Gonzalez, who in 1953 became the first Mexican American elected to the city council (see Henry B. Gonzalez, the first Mexican American on the city council). The model has lasted roughly seventy-five years, through the 2018 caps and the 2024 vote that loosened them, which suggests residents would rather adjust the arrangement than replace it. Whether the manager should have limits is a live argument, and the record shows voters have settled it both ways within six years.

What a resident should keep in mind

Three things.

  1. The council hires and can fire the manager. The people you vote for are your lever.
  2. The manager runs the departments. Day-to-day service problems go to the department or to 3-1-1.
  3. The charter can change the arrangement, and in 2024 it did. Removing the pay and tenure caps shifted more power to the council over who runs the departments, and the move to four-year terms changes how often voters can weigh in (see How four-year terms reset San Antonio's election calendar).

The city's own page for the office, at sa.gov, lists the current staff and contact information.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic