Blog
Market Square and the chili queens
A walk through San Antonio's Mexican market west of downtown, and the story of the women who sold chili on the city's plazas from the 1880s.
Head west from the courthouse and the Spanish-colonial core of downtown, and within a few blocks the sound changes. Mariachi, the smell of chiles and fried masa, strings of papel picado and the slap of a tortilla press announce Market Square, a three-block outdoor plaza of shops and restaurants billed as the largest Mexican market in the United States. It descends from a much older habit of selling food in the open on the city's plazas, and its most famous figures are the women who never held an official title: the chili queens.
What follows covers the market and the history behind it, with a clear line between what the record supports and what gets retold as legend.
The market today
Market Square comes in two parts. El Mercado, the market building, holds about 32 specialty shops. Farmers Market Plaza, across the way, holds about 80. Restaurants and bakeries serve food on the plaza, and the whole is where visitors and residents shop for pottery, textiles, jewelry and food. It hosts Cinco de Mayo celebrations in central San Antonio and many other fiestas through the year, and it is a stop for the events described in Cinco de Mayo and Diez y Seis in San Antonio. The place and its neighbors are in Market Square, and the food side in A food walk through Market Square and the old plazas.
The market building has its own history. The Works Progress Administration built El Mercado in 1938 and 1939, after the earlier municipal market house, the Giles building, was torn down. Its first name was the Municipal Truck Market, but locals called it the Farmer's Market, because farmers sold produce off their trucks in the open-air building. In 1975 the last produce was sold there, and the building became an enclosed, air-conditioned mercado.
That conversion is a small piece of social history. A market that began as an open-air place where farmers sold from trucks became, in the 1970s, a closed shopping space aimed more at visitors than at people buying vegetables. The change tracked the city's own turn toward tourism. For the economics of that shift, see tourism jobs and the hotel tax.
Where the chili queens come in
The women known as chili queens sold chili con carne and other Mexican food at open-air stalls on San Antonio's plazas. The accounts differ in several respects, and the differences are part of the story.
The standard account. Chili queens sold chili in Military Plaza from the 1880s and in front of the Alamo into the 1940s. Modern chili queens appear at Market Square, and the festival's Chili Queens Cook-off, held at the Bonham Exchange during Fiesta, takes its name from them. Most summaries tell it this way.
A more careful account. A panel discussion reported in local news coverage adds complications. Mexican American women of the late 1800s and early 1900s, the chili queens, helped turn chili con carne into a nationwide household dish. After railroads brought travelers through the city in the late 1800s, word of the tradition of serving Mexican food on city plazas spread, and Anglo entrepreneurs later sold powdered chili spices nationwide. One panelist argued that the chili queens carved out public space and made San Antonio a culinary destination. She also said that city leaders forcibly removed the chili queens from downtown plazas and mercados in 1902, citing sanitary reasons. The writer O. Henry's 1904 story "The Enchanted Kiss" describes Alamo Plaza's once-famous nightly chili festival as reduced to about half a dozen tents. And the singer Lydia Mendoza began singing alongside chili queens in West Side plazas and mercados after they were pushed out of downtown.
The two accounts disagree on when the tradition ended downtown. One says into the 1940s in front of the Alamo; the other says removal in 1902 and decline by 1904. Both may be partly right, since the practice could have gone on in reduced form or elsewhere, and the record doesn't settle it. The safe statement is that chili queens sold on the plazas from the 1880s, that efforts to remove them downtown came in the early twentieth century, and that the practice continued in some form on the West Side.
A documented life
One chili queen's story is documented in the panel report. Herminia Leal was a chili queen in the 1920s and 1930s, remembered by her granddaughter, a program manager at the Main Plaza Conservancy. She ran a booth, a baratillo, in the area that is now Market Square. Her family remembers a renowned cook whose recipe was never written down. They say Leal wouldn't have called herself a chili queen, only a woman who worked on the plaza.
That last detail changes how the label reads. "Chili queen" was a name outsiders gave to working women, and some of the women described what they did in plainer terms. A researcher on the panel said the recipes were closely guarded because the women competed with one another as businesswomen, and few were ever written down. That is why there is no authoritative recipe, and why a claim to serve the original chili queens' chili can't be checked.
From plaza stall to state dish
Chili's place in Texas life carries an official marker. In 1977 the 65th Texas Legislature declared red chili the state dish, with a resolution that recognized San Antonio as its origin but didn't mention the chili queens. The omission is the panelists' complaint: the dish is celebrated and its first makers are left out of the resolution.
The commercial side is on record too. William Gebhardt opened a chili powder factory in the late 1890s, according to the Texas State Historical Association, and the powder let people make a version of the dish at home. See William Gebhardt's chili powder and the German Texan kitchen and Red chili, the 1977 resolution and the San Antonio claim: five myths sorted out. The line from a woman at a plaza stall to a jar of powder on a grocery shelf in another state is a short one, and the railroad link in the reporting above explains how the knowledge traveled.
The recognition under way
Panel participants proposed ways to honor the women: an annual pachanga, a chili cook-off and a historical reenactment. A fandango, modeled on those of the 1700s and 1800s with food, music and dance, drew the most attention, proposed by a representative of Bexar Heritage. The Main Plaza Conservancy plans to collect oral histories from people connected to past chili queens. As of the report, these were proposals and plans, not finished projects. The existing Fiesta event, the cook-off at the Bonham Exchange, is one place the tradition is already honored; how it is run is for the organizers to say.
The numbers in one place
A few figures from the history sit well in a table.
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Shops in El Mercado | about 32 |
| Shops in Farmers Market Plaza | about 80 |
| Total shops | about 112 |
| El Mercado built (WPA) | 1938 to 1939 |
| Last produce sold, building enclosed | 1975 |
| Chili queens on the plazas | from the 1880s |
| Reported removal from downtown plazas | 1902 |
| O. Henry's story about Alamo Plaza | 1904 |
| Red chili named state dish | 1977 |
Some arithmetic: 1939 to 1975 is 36 years of produce selling in the building, and 1975 to 2026 is 51 years as an enclosed market, so the building has now spent longer as a visitor-oriented mercado than as a truck market. The chili queens' tradition is older than either. From the 1880s to the reported removal in 1902 is about two decades, and to the 1940s, in the standard account, about six. The 1977 resolution came about 90 years after the tradition began in the 1880s. The gap between the women's work and their official recognition is why the later proposals for a fandango or oral histories matter.
How to talk about the chili queens
A careful visitor will notice "chili queen" has two meanings. It names the nineteenth- and early twentieth-century women who sold from stalls, and it names the modern performers who appear at events and in the cook-off. The second use honors the first, but a costumed performer today and a woman who ran a booth in the 1920s are different things. When you meet one, ask how she thinks of the tradition. The documented testimony, that a woman who ran a booth didn't call herself a queen, is a useful correction to the romance.
How to walk it
A route through Market Square with the history in mind:
- Begin at the market building. Look at El Mercado's structure and think of it as a 1938-39 WPA building, first a truck market. The building's age is part of the lesson.
- Walk Farmers Market Plaza. It is the larger of the two parts, with about 80 shops. Notice the mix of crafts and food, and ask what in the plaza is made locally.
- Find a place to eat, standing or sitting outdoors. The chili queens' tradition was eating in the open air, and the plaza still offers that. Pick whatever stall suits you.
- Think about the plazas next door. Military Plaza, where chili queens sold from the 1880s, and Main Plaza, where the conservancy is collecting oral histories, are within walking distance of one another.
- Return in the evening or during a festival. Market Square hosts Cinco de Mayo, Diez y Seis and other events, and the energy at night is closer to the nineteenth-century plaza than a quiet weekday morning.
What the story asks of a visitor
A tourist market can turn history into decoration, and the chili queens are a case in point. The women who sold chili were working people in a competitive trade, and the plazas were their workplaces. Their story includes the removal efforts, the unrecorded recipes and the omissions from official recognition, as well as the romance. A visitor can keep both in view. For how the city's food identity has been shaped, including the UNESCO designation in 2017, see what the gastronomy designation asks of the city and The chili queens of Military Plaza. The guide to free and low-cost things to do lists more ways to spend time downtown.