Blog
How San Antonio became a UNESCO Creative City of Gastronomy
On October 31, 2017, UNESCO named San Antonio a Creative City of Gastronomy. Who applied, what the case rested on and what a designation does.
On October 31, 2017, UNESCO announced that San Antonio was now a Creative City of Gastronomy, the second in the United States. Tucson, Arizona, had been named in 2015. The announcement made a city already famous for its food a formal member of an international network and handed its food story an international label. How the designation came about, what the case for it was built from and what a reader should and should not conclude from it: that is the subject here.
What the network is
UNESCO's Creative Cities Network was launched in 2004 and names cities in several creative fields, gastronomy among them. A network summary reports that it has grown a great deal since the year San Antonio joined. When the San Antonio Chamber of Commerce described the network on the day of the announcement, it counted 180 cities in 72 countries. A reference summary for 2022 gives almost 300 cities in around 90 countries. Going from 180 to roughly 300 is growth of about two-thirds in five years, so a city that joined in 2017 joined when the club was a good deal smaller.
The network's stated aim, as the Chamber quoted it, is to put creativity and cultural industries at the core of member cities' urban development plans. The wording matters. It describes a commitment to treat food as part of a city's cultural and economic planning. It is no ranking of restaurants and no prize for a menu.
Who applied
The Chamber's release says the application process began in the spring of 2017, so the whole effort, from first meeting to announcement, took roughly half a year. The San Antonio Chamber of Commerce led it together with various departments of the City of San Antonio, and a working group of chefs and food-system people took part, among them a food magazine's publishers and a food writer, according to the release.
That mix of partners is the most useful detail in the story. A designation like this does not go to a restaurant or a company. It goes to a city, and the application needs the city's government standing behind it. The City's departments and the Chamber supplied the institutional weight, and the chefs and writers supplied the proof that the claim was true.
A local newspaper summed up the case in November 2017 under the title "20 reasons," and its list shows the kind of evidence people reach for. It cited Tex-Mex, chefs trained at the Culinary Institute of America, newer food scenes in the Pearl, Southtown and on the East Side, barbecue, steakhouses, ramen, Vietnamese, Chinese and Puerto Rican cooking, craft beer, bakeries and cocktails, and a calendar of food festivals that included a paella festival in March, restaurant weeks in January and August and a cocktail conference in January. That article is dated and names businesses that may have changed since, so its list of restaurants is not repeated here.
What the heritage case rests on
Food heritage is the other half of an application, and San Antonio's runs deep. Several pieces of it come from the Texas State Historical Association's history of the city and from other public references.
- A colonial city with a food culture from the start. Canary Islanders formed the villa of San Fernando de Bexar in 1731, adding to the Spanish mission and presidio communities founded in 1718. How their settlement fits the city's story is told in The Canary Islanders and the villa of San Fernando de Bexar.
- The chili queens. Women sold chili con carne, tamales and enchiladas at night from open-air stands in Alamo Plaza, Military Plaza, Market Square and other places. Writers such as Stephen Crane and O. Henry wrote about the scene. A San Antonio Report article records that city leaders forcibly removed the chili queens from downtown plazas in 1902, citing sanitary reasons, and that later vendors worked near what is now Market Square. Their story is in The chili queens of Military Plaza and Market Square and the chili queens.
- A chili stand at a world's fair. A reference article on chili con carne says the San Antonio Chili Stand at the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago gave many Americans their first taste of chili.
- Chili powder and canned chili. The TSHA says William Gebhardt opened a factory in the late 1890s to make chili powder, later selling it nationally, and the chili reference credits a Gebhardt with the first canned chili in 1908. That story is in William Gebhardt's chili powder and the German Texan kitchen.
- A state dish. Texas made chili con carne its official state dish in 1977. A San Antonio Report article on the chili queens notes that the 1977 legislature credited San Antonio and never mentioned the queens.
- Food labor. The Pecan Shellers' Strike of 1938 involved about 12,000 workers, most of them Mexican American women, and belongs to the food story because pecan shelling was one of the city's industries. It is told in The Pecan Shellers' Strike of 1938 and The pecan shellers and San Antonio's food economy.
- Tex-Mex as a living tradition. The puffy taco, a fried masa shell that puffs in hot oil, has been popular in the region since at least the late 1930s according to a reference article, and it is credited to a San Antonio restaurant that popularized it. See the puffy taco explained. How the older Tex-Mex tradition meets a newer, chef-driven Tex-Next cooking is the subject of Tex-Mex versus Tex-Next, two San Antonio kitchens and What Tex-Mex means in San Antonio, and what Tex-Next adds.
None of these claims is sensational. The case rests on a thick layer of ordinary evidence: a city that has fed itself and its visitors in public for centuries, in plazas, at kitchen tables and in restaurants.
The institutions that came later
A designation also rests on institutions. In 2008 the Culinary Institute of America opened a San Antonio campus at the Pearl, the former brewery complex north of downtown, and the Pearl's redevelopment as a district of restaurants, a hotel and public space is part of the modern food story. The brewery's history is in The Pearl brewery story, and the district is described in The Pearl. The Culinary Institute's role, and how culinary education fed the application, is the subject of The Culinary Institute of America in San Antonio.
Mind what is on the list and what is not. The Chamber's release never mentions the Culinary Institute, and the local newspaper article mentions a Culinary Institute graduate but gives no credit to the campus as a reason. The campus is part of the city's food world, but it should not be described as the thing that earned the designation.
Following the threads on foot
The heritage claims can be tested in person, which is the best way to understand them. Market Square, the Mexican market district west of downtown, is where the chili queens' story lands today. Market Square describes it, and A food walk through Market Square and the old plazas walks it. The Pearl, north of downtown, is where the modern culinary scene is concentrated. And the River Walk, where the city's restaurants have faced the water since the 1940s, is covered in River Walk dining from 1941 to now. Three places, three layers of the same story, all a short ride apart.
A timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1731 | Canary Islanders form the villa of San Fernando de Bexar |
| 1893 | San Antonio Chili Stand at the Chicago World's Columbian Exposition |
| Late 1890s | William Gebhardt opens a chili powder factory |
| 1902 | City leaders remove the chili queens from downtown plazas |
| 1938 | The Pecan Shellers' Strike |
| 1977 | Texas names chili con carne the official state dish |
| 2008 | Culinary Institute of America campus opens at the Pearl |
| 2015 | Tucson is named the first U.S. Creative City of Gastronomy |
| Spring 2017 | San Antonio's application process begins |
| October 31, 2017 | UNESCO names San Antonio a Creative City of Gastronomy |
What a designation does and does not do
It is tempting to treat the title as a ranking, so here is a short guide to reading it.
- It is membership in a network. The Chamber's release frames the designation as a place in an international network of cities that want to use creative fields in their planning, with 180 cities at the time.
- It is not a restaurant rating. The title honors the city's food culture as a whole. It does not say any particular restaurant is better because of it, and no list of restaurants belongs in a description of what the title means.
- It carries no stated funding amount. To see what the city has committed to since 2017, look at the city's economic development and arts and culture pages. The follow-up piece on that subject is what the gastronomy designation asks of the city.
- Its meaning is in the use. A city can use the designation in tourism marketing, in food education or in food-system planning. Which of those San Antonio has emphasized is a question about policy and not about history.
The date has a calendar echo for residents. Food events run through the year, and A month-by-month calendar of San Antonio lists the festivals that make up the food calendar, from Fiesta's food events in April to the fall events later in the year. Fiesta's food side is traced in fiesta food, day by day.
Reading the claim critically
The strongest version of the story does not say San Antonio has the best food in the country. It says the city has a continuous, documented, many-layered food tradition, and that an international body agreed the tradition was worth setting beside the other cities in its network. That claim can be checked against the record: the chili queens in the plazas, the factory in the 1890s, the strike in 1938, the state dish in 1977 and the application in 2017.
The weakest version is a restaurant list. Restaurants open and close every year, and a designation awarded to a city does not freeze its menu. What lasts is the heritage and the institutions, and the city's job, if it takes the designation seriously, is to keep them going.