Blog

City workers, unions and the ballot: two San Antonio charter votes in 2024

How AFSCME won Proposition D and the firefighters' union lost on Proposition C in November 2024, what each measure did and what supporters and opponents argued.

Election night, November 2024, and the two groups that speak for San Antonio's city workers went home with opposite results. The union that represents thousands of city employees won a measure it had spent months getting onto the ballot. The firefighters' union, which had written part of the city's rules six years earlier, lost its bid to keep them. Both were charter amendments. The margins say something about how San Antonio voters think about the people on the city payroll.

What follows is a case study from the public record: the two propositions, what each did, the arguments on each side as Texas Public Radio reported them in its voter guide and results story, and what changed. It uses titles rather than names for the people involved.

The ballot: six amendments

On November 5, 2024, San Antonio voters approved all six proposed amendments to the city charter. Early results reported by Texas Public Radio, with 150 of 302 Bexar County vote centers counted at the time:

Measure Subject Yes No
Prop A Ethics code and Ethics Review Board 72 28
Prop B Charter language clean-up 68 32
Prop C City manager pay and tenure caps 54 46
Prop D City workers' political activity 62 38
Prop E Council and mayor pay 64 36
Prop F Four-year terms 53 47

Later tallies put several of these a point higher, and certified results are the authority; the percentages here are the early figures. The full ballot, with every measure since 2024, is in The San Antonio ballot measures of 2024 through 2026, in order, and the mechanics of changing the charter are in The 20,000-signature route to amending the San Antonio charter.

Proposition D: letting city workers take part in city politics

What it did. Proposition D lifted a 72-year restriction on city employees taking part in city politics while off duty. Before it passed, city workers could not canvass for or donate to municipal candidates. After it, they can politick and campaign, including off the job. The voter guide notes that even with the change, employees could not engage in city politics on the job or in uniform.

Who pushed it. The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFSCME, lobbied for months to get the measure on the ballot, according to the public radio coverage. AFSCME represents thousands of city employees.

What the voters said. It passed in early returns, 62 to 38, a 24-point margin, and the later figure cited for the final result was about 63 percent. Of the six measures, Props A, B and E passed by wider margins.

The arguments. The public radio voter guide reported who backed the measure and what it would do, not a debate over it. The plain effect is what stands: employees barred from local campaigns for 72 years could now join them.

The voter guide spoke of canvassing and donating, and the results story said workers could campaign "ahead of the May municipal elections." The city's elections have since been moved to November of odd-numbered years, as covered in Why the council voted 6-5 to move city elections from May to November.

Proposition C: the city manager's pay and tenure

Background. In 2018 San Antonio voters approved limits on the city manager. Pay was capped at no more than ten times the lowest-paid salaried city employee, which the voter guide put at about $370,000 for the city manager. Tenure was capped at eight years. The San Antonio Professional Firefighters Association pushed for the 2018 limits during a contract fight with the city manager of the time.

A little arithmetic shows what the cap meant. If the cap was about $370,000 and was set at ten times the lowest-paid salaried employee, then that employee earned about $37,000 (370,000 divided by 10). The cap rose automatically whenever the lowest salary rose.

What it did. Proposition C removed the 2018 caps and gave the City Council authority to set the city manager's full terms of employment, pay and tenure included.

The arguments for. Council members said that since the council appoints and can remove city managers, the council should set pay and tenure. Some said recruiting a successor would be hard when the current manager's tenure ended in 2027 if candidates faced an eight-year cap.

The arguments against. Opponents said the city manager should face term limits, as elected officials do. They also argued the city could raise pay for its lowest-paid workers instead of removing the cap.

The union's position. The firefighters' union opposed Proposition C, according to the public radio results story, and lost. The association's president said the ballot language may have contributed to the result, calling it "deceptive language," while saying he did not see the outcome as a crisis because of a recent collective bargaining agreement with the city.

The vote. Proposition C passed 54 to 46, the narrowest of the measures except Proposition F at 53 to 47.

Two outcomes compared

Side by side, the two measures gave organized city workers different nights.

Proposition D Proposition C
Who pushed AFSCME Council; the firefighters' union opposed
What it did Lifted a 72-year ban on off-duty political activity Removed 2018 caps on city manager pay and tenure
Early result 62 to 38 54 to 46
Margin 24 points 8 points
Union outcome Won Lost

The margins differ by a factor of three (24 divided by 8). A measure that widened the political rights of employees sailed through. A measure that loosened the limits on a top executive's pay squeaked by. Same electorate, same day.

The cap in the scale of the budget

The city's budget helps size the pay question. The adopted budget for fiscal year 2027 is $4.41 billion across all funds, with a General Fund of $1.76 billion, according to the city's Management and Budget page. The cap discussed in 2024, about $370,000, is a different year's figure, but as a rough scale $370,000 is about 0.02 percent of a $1.76 billion General Fund (370,000 divided by 1,760,000,000 is 0.00021). That is no argument for or against the measure. Supporters were making a point about recruiting and about who sets the terms, and opponents were making one about accountability and about the lowest-paid workers, and neither depends on the share of the budget. The budget itself is explained in Inside the $4.41 billion FY 2027 budget.

How a measure reaches the charter ballot

The charter can be changed by a vote of the people, and the City Attorney's page describes one route: a petition with at least 20,000 signatures from qualified city voters. Charter elections are governed by an ordinance, Ordinance 2024-08-08-0550. The public radio coverage shows a second route in practice: AFSCME lobbied successfully to get Proposition D on the ballot, so the measure reached voters through persuading the city rather than through a signature drive. The rules for the other routes are on the City Attorney's page.

A timeline

Year Event
1951 The current city charter is adopted
2018 Voters set the city manager pay and tenure limits; the firefighters' union pushed them
November 5, 2024 Voters approve all six amendments
December 18, 2025 The council votes 6 to 5 to move city elections to November of odd-numbered years
2027 The year Proposition C's supporters cited for the end of the current manager's tenure
2029 The next council and mayoral election, under four-year terms

The charter itself dates to 1951, and its history is covered in the 1951 charter and the commission that wrote it.

Two other measures of the six touch city workers. Proposition E raised council pay from $45,722 to $70,200 and the mayor's from $61,725 to $87,800, adjusted annually to the HUD median income for a four-person San Antonio household. The raises come to roughly $24,500 and $26,100 (70,200 minus 45,722, and 87,800 minus 61,725). Supporters said low pay limited service to wealthy residents. Opponents, including the council's three lawyers, called it a poor use of tax dollars, and members may decline the pay. Proposition F moved to four-year terms with a two-term limit. See What San Antonio's council members and mayor are paid after Proposition E and How four-year terms reset San Antonio's election calendar.

Proposition A, which passed 72 to 28 in early returns, defined conflicts of interest and funded the Ethics Review Board, the 11-member citizen board that enforces ethics, lobbying and campaign finance rules; see The 11-member Ethics Review Board and what voters changed in 2024.

What the vote shows and what it cannot

A few conclusions hold. Voters approved all six amendments in 2024. The union representing thousands of city workers got what it wanted on Proposition D. The firefighters' union did not get what it wanted on Proposition C, and its president pointed at the ballot language. The council gained the power to set the city manager's pay and tenure, with the offices of manager and council described in City Manager's Office and what a city manager does in a council-manager city.

Motive is another matter. Whether voters passed Proposition D because they like city workers, because they thought a 72-year-old rule was dated, or because of how the measure was worded, no vote count can say. The same goes for Proposition C. Turnout figures for these measures are not part of what is reported here.

For readers who follow city politics, the practical points are modest. City employees can now take part in local campaigns off duty. The council now sets the manager's terms. City elections are moving to November of odd-numbered years, and voters next elect the mayor and council in 2029. To vote, see how to register to vote and find your polling place. The structure of city government is in How San Antonio city government works, and the longer charter history is in the 1951 charter and the commission that wrote it.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic