Blog
What the gastronomy designation asks of the city
UNESCO named San Antonio a Creative City of Gastronomy on October 31, 2017, the second U.S.
San Antonio carries two UNESCO titles, and they came two years apart. In 2015 the Alamo and the four other Spanish missions were inscribed as a World Heritage Site. On October 31, 2017, UNESCO named San Antonio a Creative City of Gastronomy, the second city in the United States to get the title, after Tucson, Arizona, named in 2015. The first protects places. The second honors a food culture, which is harder to define, harder to protect and a lot easier to argue about.
Consider this a case piece. It lays out what the designation is, how the city got it, what it was expected to do, and the questions a title like this leaves with the people who live under it.
What the title is
UNESCO's Creative Cities Network dates to 2004, and its purpose is to promote cooperation among cities that treat culture and creativity as drivers of sustainable urban development. When the San Antonio Chamber of Commerce announced the title in November 2017, the network counted 180 cities in 72 countries. Cities are designated in seven creative fields: crafts and folk art, design, film, gastronomy, literature, music and media arts. San Antonio's field is gastronomy.
Two things it is not. It is not a ranking of restaurants, and it certifies no business. It is a designation of the city as a whole, based on its food heritage and its plans for it. And it is separate from the World Heritage listing, which concerns specific sites. The Chamber's announcement notes that the gastronomy title is the city's second UNESCO designation.
How the bid came together
The Chamber's announcement gives the outline of the application. The work began in the spring of 2017. A working group led by a local chef pulled in city departments, other food professionals, food writers and the Chamber. The Chamber's part grew out of a task force on what it calls Good to Great to Global, specifically its Cultural Preservation and Celebration focus area, which the Chamber's chairman had created the year before. So the structure was a group of food practitioners, city departments and the business community, working over a few months.
Look at who was in the room. City departments, chefs, a food publication, food writers and the Chamber are all named. The Culinary Institute of America's San Antonio campus and the Pearl are not named as bid participants, though both belong to the city's food story, and a news account of the designation lists the Pearl and Southtown among the city's dining districts. Community organizations such as the markets or the pecan-shelling families are not named as part of the bid either. That is worth noticing, because the food heritage the bid describes was largely made by working people, a point taken up below.
What the city said it would gain
The Chamber's page cites broader tourism and economic benefits, a showcase for local culture on a global platform, and a stronger position for San Antonio as an international hub for business and quality of life. It says the designation offers expanded chances to attract tourists by displaying the city's cultural assets. It gives no specific targets or figures.
That silence matters. A title with no numbers attached cannot be judged a success or a failure on its own terms. Compare the tourism economy, which does have numbers: the city's hotel occupancy tax adds up to 17 percent in all, including the 2 percent for Convention Center expansion. A tourism marketing push can be measured against hotel tax receipts. A cultural designation is measured, if at all, by whether the culture it names is still around in a decade. See What visitors pay in hotel taxes, and why San Antonians should care and tourism jobs and the hotel tax.
What the designation draws on
A news account published two days after the announcement lists strengths that were part of the case: Tex-Mex and interior Mexican cooking, a widening range of cuisines including Korean, pan-Asian and contemporary American, barbecue, steakhouses and Italian restaurants, ramen, Vietnamese, Chinese and Puerto Rican food, the Pearl and Southtown as dining districts, restaurant and food festivals, bakeries, craft cocktails, craft beer and Mediterranean food. That is the city's food scene as of 2017, not UNESCO's own reasons.
The deeper history is documented elsewhere in the city's record.
- The chili queens. Mexican American women sold chili from stalls on the plazas, helping turn chili con carne into a national dish; the story is in Market Square and the chili queens.
- Chili powder. William Gebhardt opened a chili powder factory in the late 1890s. See William Gebhardt's chili powder and the German Texan kitchen.
- The state dish. In 1977 the Texas Legislature declared red chili the official state dish, recognizing San Antonio as its origin.
- The pecan shellers. In 1938 about 12,000 pecan shellers, mostly Mexican American women, walked out in the largest strike in the city's history, as told in The Pecan Shellers' Strike of 1938.
- The puffy taco and Tex-Mex. The city's food is described in the puffy taco explained, What Tex-Mex means in San Antonio, and what Tex-Next adds and Tex-Mex versus Tex-Next, two San Antonio kitchens.
Two designations, side by side
The city's two UNESCO titles are different kinds of recognition, and a comparison shows how.
| World Heritage Site | Creative City of Gastronomy | |
|---|---|---|
| Year | 2015 | 2017 (October 31) |
| What it covers | The Alamo and the four other Spanish missions | The city's food culture |
| Kind of thing | Specific places | A living practice |
| Network | World Heritage list | Creative Cities Network, created 2004 |
| Fellow U.S. example | Not described in the sources | Tucson, 2015, the first U.S. city |
The Creative Cities Network had 180 cities in 72 countries when the Chamber wrote its announcement, an average of two and a half cities per country (180 divided by 72). San Antonio was one of only two in the United States in the gastronomy field. From the bid's start in the spring of 2017 to the designation on October 31 was a matter of months, perhaps six to eight depending on when in the spring the work began, which is quick for an international application.
A heritage listing protects a place by limiting what can be done to it. A creative-city title protects nothing by law. That is why the questions below are about practice and not regulation. A rule can preserve a building. A food culture survives only if people keep cooking, buying and selling it.
Measuring a title
No figure exists for what the designation has done. A resident or a reporter who wanted to measure it could look at a few indicators, each public in principle:
- Visitor spending. The city's hotel occupancy tax receipts, taxed at a combined 17 percent, rise and fall with tourism, though many things move them.
- Food businesses. The count of licensed food establishments, which Metro Health keeps, shows whether the food economy is growing.
- Training and jobs. Enrollment and placement at the culinary programs the city hosts.
- Events and festivals. Whether the city's food events grow and who runs them.
None of these isolates the effect of a title. They are the evidence a careful observer would use, read together over years. One year's change proves little.
Questions the title leaves open
A good case piece ends with what a reasonable person would ask. These are questions, not positions, and the record does not answer them.
What does the city owe the people behind the food? The history above is a history of working women: chili queens on the plazas, pecan shellers in factories. A designation that celebrates their food invites the question of whether it also attends to their descendants' wages and conditions. The pecan shellers earned a few dollars a week per family in the 1930s, according to the state handbook. Supporters of the designation would say recognition raises the profile of the food economy and the jobs in it. Skeptics could answer that a title does not change a pay scale. The record holds no measurement either way.
Who is responsible for the designation's upkeep? UNESCO's network involves membership and cooperation among cities, and the Chamber's announcement lists no commitments by San Antonio or its partners. Whether a standing office or program exists, and who staffs it, is not settled. A reader who wants to know should ask the city and the Chamber.
How do inspections and licensing fit? Food safety is the unglamorous side of a food city. The city's Metro Health Department inspects food establishments and issues licenses, as described in San Antonio Metropolitan Health District, and the scoring is explained in How San Antonio restaurant inspection reports work. A food city's reputation rests on safe kitchens, and the designation does not change what an inspector looks for.
Does a title change what a visitor sees? The Chamber expected expanded tourism. For a visitor, the visible effects would be in marketing and events. A resident might ask something else: does the city's food scene, from a taquería to a high-end restaurant, stay affordable to the people who live here? That is an economic question the designation is not built to answer.
Reading the designation as a tool
Used well, a designation like this is a tool for telling the city's story to outsiders and focusing local attention on what is worth keeping. The better way to read it is as a commitment to a conversation, not a trophy. A few practical signs of whether the conversation is happening are open to any resident:
- Whether the city's tourism materials describe the food heritage accurately, including the chili queens and the pecan shellers.
- Whether food events, such as the Fiesta Chili Queens Cook-off and the neighborhood festivals, include the communities that made the dishes.
- Whether the Culinary Institute and other training programs connect to jobs in the city's kitchens. The campus is covered in The Culinary Institute of America in San Antonio.
- Whether new food businesses can find affordable space in neighborhoods and markets, not just in new districts.
The date and the facts are settled: October 31, 2017, the second U.S. city after Tucson. The rest is up to the people who cook, serve, regulate and eat in the city. The broader story of how the title came about is told in the companion post on how San Antonio became a city of gastronomy, and the Pearl and Market Square neighborhood records cover two of the city's food districts.