Blog

Tex-Mex versus Tex-Next, two San Antonio kitchens

How the older San Antonio cooking of puffy tacos, chili stands and combination plates compares with the newer chef-driven style that local coverage calls.

Ask a San Antonian where to eat and you will often get two answers that sound as if they came from different cities. One is a place with a laminated menu, a basket of chips on the table before you sit and enchiladas under a blanket of melted cheese. The other lists the farm each vegetable came from and puts a Texas ingredient into a dish that is not obviously Mexican or American. Both answers are right. They describe two kitchens that share a city, a pantry and a history, and have spent a few years getting along and arguing. This piece sets them side by side without ranking a single restaurant, because the useful question is not who is best but what each style is trying to do.

A word on terms. "Tex-Mex" is the older and better-known label. "Tex-Next" is a newer coinage that turns up in San Antonio food coverage for a generation of chefs who start from Tex-Mex and push it somewhere else. Neither term has a legal definition, and nobody can issue you a Tex-Mex license. They are shorthand, and shorthand is the right level here.

The older kitchen

Tex-Mex is the cooking of the Mexican American communities of South Texas, shaped by what ranches, markets and border towns had on hand. In San Antonio its public life began on the street. Chili queens sold chili from stands in Military Plaza from the 1880s, and in front of the Alamo into the 1940s. The stands were as much a place to meet as a place to eat, and visitors wrote about them for decades. The story is in The chili queens of Military Plaza, and modern chili queens still turn up at Market Square and at Fiesta's Chili Queens Cook-off, held at the Bonham Exchange during Fiesta.

Chili went from the street to the kitchen and the pantry by way of industry. William Gebhardt opened a chili powder factory in San Antonio in the late 1890s, per the Texas State Historical Association, putting a bottled seasoning into kitchens across the country; see William Gebhardt's chili powder and the German Texan kitchen. Texas later named red chili its official state dish, in 1977 by most accounts. See Red chili, the 1977 resolution and the San Antonio claim: five myths sorted out.

The cooking that grew out of that history has recognizable habits. These describe the style, not any particular restaurant:

  • The combination plate. Several small items, typically an enchilada, a taco, rice and beans, arrive together on one oval plate.
  • Cheese, usually melted. Yellow or white, spread over enchiladas and nachos.
  • Chile con carne gravy and red sauces. Built on dried chiles and cumin, and often simmered rather than blended fresh.
  • Flour and corn tortillas, both. Flour for tacos and fajitas, corn for enchiladas and chips.
  • The puffy taco. A corn masa shell fried so it puffs and stays tender in the center instead of shattering. It is a local dish and a point of civic pride; the puffy taco explained takes it apart. Henry's Puffy Tacos is the restaurant name people most often attach to it.

This is food built for a table of eight with a pitcher and a basket, and built to be recognizable from one restaurant to the next. That is a virtue, not a flaw. Familiar food at a fair price is what a place like this is for. For a fuller account of what the term means locally, read What Tex-Mex means in San Antonio, and what Tex-Next adds.

The newer kitchen

Tex-Next is harder to pin down, and that is by design. Coverage uses the label for chefs who grew up eating the older food, trained somewhere that cooked differently and came home. They take Tex-Mex flavors, such as dried chiles, masa, charred peppers, lime and pecan, and rebuild them with other techniques. They also take Texas ingredients, such as local produce, heritage grains, Gulf seafood and Hill Country game, and put them in dishes that cite Mexican cooking without copying it.

A few things tend to set the approach apart:

  • The menu is shorter and changes. A page of 60 items is a Tex-Mex signal. A dozen items, reprinted seasonally, signal the other kitchen.
  • Sourcing is part of the pitch. The menu names producers and regions.
  • Masa and tortillas are made in house. Nixtamalization, treating corn with an alkaline solution so it makes proper dough, is the technique chefs in this style cite most. It is more labor than buying tortillas.
  • Plating is deliberate. There is a center of the plate and a composition around it.
  • Prices are higher. Labor, sourcing and smaller dining rooms all push the check up.

The city has a stage for this at the Pearl, a former brewery complex on the river north of downtown, and in the neighborhoods around it. See The Pearl and The Pearl: from brewery to neighborhood on the Museum Reach. A professional cooking school, the Culinary Institute of America campus, has also been in San Antonio for years and trains cooks who stay; see The Culinary Institute of America in San Antonio. That says nothing about any one chef, only about the supply of trained cooks.

Side by side

Older Tex-Mex Newer Tex-Next
Where it comes from Mexican American home and street cooking of South Texas The same pantry, filtered through professional training
What it promises Familiar food, generous plates, a fair price A dish you have not had before, built on a local ingredient
Menu Long, stable Short, seasonal
Signature technique Slow-simmered chile sauces, frying, the griddle Nixtamalized masa, live-fire cooking, aging, pickling
How you eat Family-style, a basket and a pitcher Plates, often shared, often smaller
What it costs Moderate Higher
The risk Sameness Preciousness

The table is a caricature, and every restaurant breaks it somewhere. A taqueria can source with a care that would embarrass a chef with a farm map on the wall, and a fine-dining room can cook a pot of beans that would not look out of place at a plate lunch. That is why the labels are only handles.

Not enemies

The fight food writers sometimes stage, old versus new, authentic versus creative, mostly dissolves when you look at the people. A cook in either kitchen learned from somebody's grandmother. The difference is what each was asked to do with it.

The city's culinary standing matters here because it did not come from either side alone. In October 2017, UNESCO designated San Antonio a Creative City of Gastronomy, the second in the United States after Tucson. The recognition took in markets, home cooks, bakeries, the chili tradition and the professional kitchens together, and it carries obligations described in what the gastronomy designation asks of the city. See also How San Antonio became a UNESCO Creative City of Gastronomy.

Labor is a third strand running under both kitchens. The pecan shellers who struck in 1938, in a strike led by Emma Tenayuca, were workers in the city's food economy, and the roots of the cooking cannot be pulled apart from the work that fed it. See The Pecan Shellers' Strike of 1938 and The pecan shellers and San Antonio's food economy.

Reading a menu for each

If you want the older style, look for:

  1. Combination plates, listed by number.
  2. A puffy taco, usually with a choice of fillings.
  3. Fajitas, enchiladas and tacos al pastor in the same section.
  4. A Fiesta season. The older restaurants and the market stalls get busiest in the weeks of Fiesta; the festival is covered in Fiesta San Antonio 2026 and its eleven days, April 16 to 26.

If you want the newer style, look for:

  1. A short menu that names its producers.
  2. A tortilla made on the premises.
  3. An ingredient you do not usually see on a Tex-Mex plate, such as a Gulf fish, a heritage corn or a wild-collected herb.
  4. A tasting or set menu option.

A fair test

Say two friends want to settle it over a long weekend. They could eat at a family-run lunch counter where the plate lands in four minutes for a modest price. Then they could book a seat at a chef-driven restaurant at the Pearl, spend several times as much and sit for two hours. That comparison teaches the one thing that matters: the older kitchen is built for the hundredth plate of the day and the newer one for the first plate of the evening. Neither can do the other's job, and each fails if it tries.

Cost matters more than people remember. A city with a large population on modest incomes needs restaurants that feed a family for a reasonable price, and their abundance is part of why San Antonio is a good place to eat. A city with a growing professional class and a flow of visitors also supports restaurants that ask more of the diner. San Antonio has both, which is rarer than it sounds.

What both owe the street

The thread between the two kitchens is the one that started at Military Plaza. The chili queens cooked outdoors, for a mixed crowd, and made the city's food a public thing. The Market Square district, west of downtown, still holds that spirit with its stalls and plazas, and A food walk through Market Square and the old plazas walks through it. Market Square describes the district. A sit-down restaurant of either kind inherits a version of that tradition. The question for a newer restaurant is whether it is still, in some way, cooking for the city. The question for an older one is whether it is still, in some way, curious.

For more, River Walk dining from 1941 to now covers the other half of the city's dining history, the half that grew up along the river, and A year of San Antonio food events lays out the year's food calendar.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic