Blog
The Pecan Shellers' Strike of 1938
About 12,000 San Antonio pecan shellers, mostly Mexican American women, struck in January 1938 over a one-cent cut.
One cent a pound. That was the cut. On January 31, 1938, pay for shelled pecan halves dropped from seven cents a pound to six, pieces fell from six cents to five, and the rate for crackers went from 50 cents to 40 cents per hundred pounds. About 12,000 shellers, roughly two-thirds of the city's pecan shelling workforce, walked out that day. The strike lasted until March 8, when both sides agreed to arbitration, and it is described as the largest labor strike in San Antonio's history.
What follows is the strike told in order: the pay, the people, the police response, the settlement and what came next. Where historians differ, the difference is said plainly.
The trade
San Antonio in the 1930s was the center of an industry most Americans never gave a thought. Texas grew about 40 percent of the national pecan crop, and half of that came from within 250 miles of San Antonio. The city was called the world's largest pecan shelling center. The work fell mainly to Mexican American women, usually by hand, and the pay was very low: the state's historical handbook puts family earnings at about $2 to $3 a week, while another account says about $1 to $4.
Run the numbers on the workforce. If 12,000 shellers were two-thirds of it, the whole workforce was about 18,000 (12,000 divided by two-thirds). In a city of a few hundred thousand people in the 1930s, tens of thousands depended on a trade that paid a few dollars a week per family.
The biggest employer was the Southern Pecan Shelling Company, owned by Julius Seligman, which shelled roughly a quarter to a third of the nation's output. The work ran on a contract system. The company sold whole pecans to contractors at 10 cents a pound and bought the shelled nuts back at 30 to 36 cents a pound, and the contractors paid the shellers. That is how the pay cut came down through the contractors as it did.
Earlier strikes in 1934 and 1935 had failed. By January 1938 these workers had tried before and lost.
The cut in percentages
The January 31 cuts were one cent on halves, one cent on pieces and ten cents per hundred pounds on crackers. They sound small. In percentages they were not. One cent off seven is about 14 percent (1 divided by 7). One cent off six is about 17 percent (1 divided by 6). Ten cents off 50 is 20 percent. For people earning a few dollars a week for a whole family, a cut of between a seventh and a fifth of the rate could be the difference between a week with enough to eat and a week without.
The leader and the union
Emma Tenayuca was not a sheller. She was born December 21, 1916, in San Antonio, and in 1938 she was 21. She had been arrested for the first time at 16, in 1933, while picketing the Finck Cigar Company, and had graduated from Brackenridge High School in 1934. She led the Workers Alliance, which she said had more than 10,000 members, and the strikers elected her chair of the strike committee. By one account the Workers Alliance of America was founded in 1935 by the Communist Party USA as a front organization, a fact that shaped much of the response to the strike.
Under pressure from inside the union, the United Cannery, Agricultural, Packing and Allied Workers of America, over her communist ties, she stepped down, and the union's president, Donald Henderson, replaced her. The state handbook says more than 10,000 workers, mostly women, struck the Southern Pecan Shelling Company for three months.
Tenayuca later taught in the Harlandale School District until she retired in 1982. She died on July 23, 1999. Her later education and work, a master's degree in education among them, are recorded in the biographies. The labor and political questions of her life belong to the historians. Her role in 1938 is the point here: a 21-year-old who chaired a committee of thousands.
The response
The strike met strong opposition, and the response is well documented.
- City officials. The mayor and other officials used red-baiting, labeling the strikers communists, to turn public opinion against them, and it largely worked, by one account. The police chief denied a strike existed, calling it a communist ploy.
- Arrests. Hundreds of protesters and pickets were arrested, Tenayuca among them. One account says police imprisoned roughly 1,000 strikers. All soup kitchens in the city closed to strikers.
- The state. Governor James V. Allred ordered an investigation, and a commission found on February 14 that the police had exceeded their authority, but no action was taken against them.
- The church and the press. Archbishop Arthur Jerome Drossaerts publicly opposed the strike. La Prensa, a major Spanish-language newspaper, supported the strikers. The newspaper's story is in La Prensa, KCOR and Spanish-language media.
- Allies. Texas Representative Maury Maverick backed the strikers, and the American Civil Liberties Union began helping them.
A fair account holds two things at once. City officials said they were answering a communist-led disruption, and the strikers said they were workers asking not to be paid less. The commission's finding, that the police had gone beyond their authority, is a matter of record. What drove the officials is described differently by different accounts, and a reader may weigh them differently.
The settlement
The strike ended March 8, 1938, when both sides agreed to arbitration. The three-member panel included Austin's mayor, Robert Thomas Miller. Its decision, issued April 13, raised wages by one-half cent over previous rates and made the union local the sole legal representative of the shellers. Observers considered the award more favorable to employers than to workers.
A half-cent raise on a six- or seven-cent rate restores about half of the January cut. On halves the pay had fallen from seven cents to six. A half cent over the previous rates brings it, depending on how the award is read, to six and a half or seven and a half. Which base the half cent was added to is unsettled, so the final rate is left unstated.
Two forces that ended the trade
What came next shows the strike's outcome mattered less to the workers' livelihoods than two changes from outside.
The minimum wage. The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 set a 25-cent minimum wage, which took effect in October and raised shellers' pay. The law was a federal answer to the problem the strike had made public.
The machines. Fearing mechanization, the union and the companies together sought an exemption for pecan shelling from the minimum wage. It was denied. The industry mechanized anyway, and by 1941 about 10,000 shellers had permanently lost their jobs, though many found work during the military buildup of the Second World War.
Follow the sequence. A cut in 1938 led to a strike. A federal wage floor raised pay. Higher labor costs made machines the better buy, and by 1941 the hand-shelling workforce had shrunk by about 10,000 people, more than half of the 18,000 estimated above (10,000 divided by 18,000 is 0.56). The workers' success in raising pay was followed by the loss of the jobs. Historians cite it as a hard lesson about labor in mechanizing industries. Many of the 10,000 found other work, though how many is not recorded.
The dates in order
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1933 | Tenayuca, then 16, first arrested while picketing a cigar company |
| 1934 and 1935 | Earlier mass strikes in the pecan industry fail |
| January 31, 1938 | Pay cut; about 12,000 shellers walk out |
| February 14, 1938 | State commission finds police exceeded their authority |
| March 8, 1938 | Both sides agree to arbitration |
| April 13, 1938 | Arbitration decision: a half-cent raise and union recognition |
| October 1938 | Federal minimum wage of 25 cents takes effect |
| 1941 | About 10,000 shellers permanently out of work |
From the walkout on January 31 to the agreement to arbitrate on March 8 is 36 days (28 days from January 31 to February 28, then 8 more to March 8; 1938 was not a leap year). The handbook's phrase "three months" is looser, and it may count the stretch through the April decision. From the strike to the loss of 10,000 jobs is three years, the span in which the trade changed shape.
Who the strikers were
They were mainly Mexican American women, and the individual stories mostly went unrecorded, so none are supplied here. What the record supports is the scale and the conditions: 12,000 walked out, pay per family was a few dollars a week, soup kitchens closed to them, and hundreds were arrested. The organized voice of the strike came from a union local and a young committee chair, but the strike itself was the act of thousands of people who left their tables on one winter morning. The Avenida Guadalupe area, the center of West Side Mexican American life, is described in Avenida Guadalupe.
What the strike left behind
- Politics. Maury Maverick, who had lost his seat in Congress, became mayor of San Antonio with major support from Mexican American voters.
- Writing. Tenayuca later wrote "The Mexican Question in the Southwest," discussing the strike and the issues facing Mexican Americans.
- Memory. A bilingual children's book about the strike, "That's Not Fair! Emma Tenayuca's Struggle for Justice," keeps the story in schools, and the South Texas Civil Rights Project gives an annual Emma Tenayuca Award.
- The food economy. The pecan industry is part of the city's food history, explored in The pecan shellers and San Antonio's food economy and, in the context of the city's UNESCO designation, in what the gastronomy designation asks of the city.
- The labor story. The city's later labor history, including public employees' unions, is covered in City workers, unions and the ballot: two San Antonio charter votes in 2024.
Where to see it
The strike's world was the West Side. The Avenida Guadalupe district and the plazas of Market Square were the heart of the Mexican American community in those years, and their records are in Avenida Guadalupe and Market Square. The Market Square story overlaps that of the chili queens, women who also worked the plazas, told in Market Square and the chili queens. The city has kept the memory of the strike alive in its civic life. Walk through the plaza with the numbers in your head: 12,000 workers, a one-cent cut, a three-month strike, and a trade that lasted only three more years in its old form.