Blog

The pecan shellers and San Antonio's food economy

About 12,000 mostly Mexican American women shelled pecans by hand in 1930s San Antonio at pennies a pound. The wage arithmetic and the machines.

Ask where San Antonio's food story begins and most people say chili, tamales, tacos, the dishes a visitor orders. Start instead with a nut. In the 1930s San Antonio was a national center of pecan shelling, and the work was done largely by hand, by Mexican American women, at rates paid by the pound. It is usually told as labor history, and it is that. It is also food history, because it shows who made the city's food business run and what they were paid to do it.

How big it was

The account of the 1938 strike gives the scale. The employer at the center of it, the Southern Pecan Shelling Company, shelled between a quarter and a third of the nation's pecans. About 12,000 shellers took part in the 1938 strike, roughly two-thirds of the industry's workforce, and the account calls it the largest labor strike in San Antonio's history. Most of the shellers were Mexican American women.

The numbers imply something simple. If 12,000 shellers were about two-thirds of the workforce, the whole workforce ran about 18,000. That is a lot of people in one food-processing trade in a city whose population was 253,854 in 1940, according to the Texas State Historical Association's census table. By that count pecan shelling employed something like 7 percent of the city's total population (18,000 divided by 253,854), workers alone, families not included. It is an estimate drawn from two numbers, good only for order of magnitude. This was not a side trade.

How the industry fits with the rest of the city's food culture is less direct, and history has not tied the two together tightly. The chili queens, the tamale makers and the restaurant cooks of the same decades are covered in The chili queens of Military Plaza. The pecan trade was a second, parallel food economy, one that shipped a raw product out of town to buyers across the country.

How the pay worked

Shellers were paid by the pound, which is why the strike started over fractions of a cent. The trigger came on January 31, 1938, when contractors cut pay three ways:

  • Shelled halves: from 7 cents to 6 cents per pound.
  • Pieces: from 6 cents to 5 cents per pound.
  • Crackers: from 50 cents to 40 cents per 100 pounds.

The percentages show what those pennies meant. A drop from 7 cents to 6 is a cut of 14 percent (1 divided by 7). From 6 to 5 is about 17 percent. And 50 cents to 40 cents per 100 pounds is 20 percent. For people already paid pennies, cuts that size were large.

A piece rate works differently from an hourly wage. The worker is paid for what she finishes, so every slow minute, every cracked half and every bad nut comes out of her own pocket, and a cut of a cent a pound lands on earnings that were already thin. That is why a one-cent change, trivial on paper, was enough to bring thousands of workers out of the shelling sheds.

A hypothetical shows the effect. Daily output varied from worker to worker, so the figure here is made up for the example. Say a sheller picked 20 pounds of halves in a day. At 7 cents a pound that is $1.40, and at 6 cents it is $1.20, a difference of 20 cents. A different real figure would scale in proportion, but the point holds: the cut came out of very small daily earnings.

The strike

The strike ran from January 31 to March 8, 1938. Its organizer was Emma Tenayuca, who was not a sheller but led the Workers Alliance and whom the strikers elected committee chair. Under pressure from inside the union over her communist affiliation, she stepped down and another organizer replaced her.

The city came down hard. The mayor and other officials used red-baiting against the strikers. Hundreds of picketers and protesters were arrested, Tenayuca among them. Every soup kitchen in the city was closed to strikers. The governor ordered an investigation, which found the police had overstepped their authority, though no action was taken against them. The strike had allies: a congressman backed it, the ACLU offered help and the Spanish-language newspaper La Prensa was sympathetic. A rally at Military Plaza on March 19 celebrated the release of some of the jailed strikers. The newspaper's history is in La Prensa, KCOR and Spanish-language media.

The blow-by-blow is told in The Pecan Shellers' Strike of 1938. What counts here is the outcome. On March 8 both sides agreed to arbitration and the shellers went back to work, and an April 13 panel decision granted a half-cent-per-pound increase. The union local was recognized as the shellers' sole legal representative.

A half cent is a little over 7 percent of 7 cents. Applied to shelled halves, it would bring the rate from 6 cents to 6.5, restoring half of the one-cent cut. That is an illustration of scale, not a finding about the award.

The minimum wage and the machines

The settlement did not last, and national law was the reason. The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 set a minimum wage of 25 cents an hour, effective that October. Requests to exempt the shellers from the law were denied.

That ruling carried the consequence the shellers feared. A piece rate paid by the pound is cheap when labor is cheap, and a legal wage floor changes the sums. The industry feared the minimum wage would drive costs up, and it answered by automating. By 1941 about 10,000 shellers had permanently lost their jobs, though many found work during World War II.

The loss in plain arithmetic is stark. If about 12,000 shellers struck and about 10,000 lost their jobs by 1941, roughly five of every six strikers' jobs were gone in under three years (10,000 divided by 12,000 is about 83 percent). The two figures do not count the same group, since the 10,000 are shellers displaced by machines and the 12,000 are those who struck, so the comparison is approximate. It still shows what mechanization did to the trade.

That is what keeps the story from being a simple victory or a simple defeat. The workers won recognition and a raise in the spring of 1938, and by 1941 the jobs those wins were meant to protect were mostly gone. Readers draw different lessons. One is that a minimum wage helped workers in other trades and hurt the shellers in theirs. Another is that the machines were coming anyway. The sequence is on the record. The lesson is the reader's.

A pecan on the table

It is easy to eat a pecan without thinking of the hands that opened it. A pecan pie, a praline, a spoonful of pecans over a dish of sweet potatoes: each began as a nut in a shell that somebody cracked and picked clean, one at a time, in a crowded shed. In 1930s San Antonio, that somebody was most often a Mexican American woman working at a rate that did not change much whether she was quick or slow, and a rate that, when it dropped by a cent, took money out of a family's week.

The strike put the work on a national map for a few weeks in 1938. The machines that came afterward took it off again. What stayed is the plain fact that one of the city's biggest food industries once rested on people the city mostly did not name.

What happened to the people

The last notes are political. Maury Maverick, the congressman who had backed the strike and had lost his House seat, won the San Antonio mayoral race in 1938 with strong Mexican American support. The strike was one of the events that shaped city politics in the year it happened.

The women themselves are harder to trace. A few organizers and officials are named, and the account says only that many shellers found work during the war. That is typical of labor history for low-wage workers, and it is why local archives and oral histories matter. The Texana Resource Center at the Central Library, which reopened after a $4.55 million renovation, is one place to ask about such collections. See The Central Library and the Texana Resource Center.

Pecans and the city's food identity

When San Antonio was named a UNESCO Creative City of Gastronomy in 2017, the story told about its food was mostly dishes and chefs. The pecan story adds another note: a food economy defined by labor. The designation's own story is in How San Antonio became a UNESCO Creative City of Gastronomy.

The plazas and markets where the city's food was sold, Market Square above all, are described in Market Square, and the West Side cultural corridor, where much of the city's Mexican American life was concentrated, is in Avenida Guadalupe. The shellers worked across the West Side and its crowded rental districts rather than in one named place.

Reading a labor story carefully

Three habits help with any history like this.

  1. Keep the numbers apart by year and by what they count. The 12,000 strikers, the 18,000 implied workforce and the 10,000 displaced shellers are three different counts, and they should not be added or subtracted without saying what each measures.
  2. Convert before comparing. The cuts, the raise and the minimum wage were set in different units, pounds and hours, and comparing them takes some conversion.
  3. Notice who is named. Officials and organizers appear by name and the shellers mostly do not, a silence in the record and not in the story.

The food on San Antonio's tables has always rested on people whose work was hard and whose names went unrecorded. The shellers of 1938 are one of the few such groups whose story has been told in detail.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic